High-Precision-Congestion-Control icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
High-Precision-Congestion-Control copied to clipboard

Regenerate fig 11c from HPCC paper

Open sana-mahmood opened this issue 3 years ago • 2 comments

Hi, I am trying to recreate fig 11c (fat-tree topology with 50% background fbHadoop traffic). I use run.py to generate config files for each scheme. I am able to get expected results for HPCC and DCTCP, but for DCQCN and TIMELY my values are much more inflated than in the paper. I was wondering if there is any optimization done for DCQCN and TIMELY for the experiments in paper that I am missing out in my experiments, like some particular parameter value?

Thanks

sana-mahmood avatar Jan 20 '22 19:01 sana-mahmood

Hi Sana, would you like to share your results for DCQCN and TIMELY with your parameters so that we have better understanding on your settings?

rmiao avatar Mar 10 '22 02:03 rmiao

Hello, sorry for responding quite late here (it slipped through the cracks) but I would really appreciate your help. Here are my config files for DCQCN and TIMELY with their results

DCQCN config: config_dcqcn.txt

TIMELY config: config_timely.txt

FCT Slowdown Results: For timely, timely_win, dcqcn and dcqcn_win, my results have higher values compared to those in the paper

image

Paper Result for comaprison:

image

Thank you for taking the time to answer my question!

sana-mahmood avatar Sep 28 '22 18:09 sana-mahmood