zoxide icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
zoxide copied to clipboard

Support the `--` command-line argument

Open igor-akhmetov opened this issue 10 months ago • 6 comments

A very minor request, but it'd be nice if zoxide supported the -- command-line argument similar to how cd does it. Right now zoxide treats it as a path and reports that "no match found".

A use case scenario with bash:

  1. Use zoxide init bash --cmd cd to replace the built-in cd.
  2. Set shopt -s autocd to make bash automatically cd when a command name is a directory.
  3. Enter a command name that is a directory. Bash uses cd -- <path>, the cd alias expands to a zoxide command, and zoxide fails because it doesn't recognize --.

igor-akhmetov avatar Mar 31 '24 18:03 igor-akhmetov

+1. Just came here to report that zoxide isn't working with autocd.

pallaswept avatar Apr 19 '24 00:04 pallaswept

Here's a workaround for anyone else who is trying to get this to behave - we will override the internal zoxide function and catch the leading -- before it is passed along with another -- making an invalid set of arguments:

function __zoxide_z() {
    # shellcheck disable=SC2199
    if [[ $# -eq 0 ]]; then
        __zoxide_cd ~
    elif [[ $# -eq 1 && $1 == '-' ]]; then
        __zoxide_cd "${OLDPWD}"
    elif [[ $# -eq 1 && -d $1 ]]; then
        __zoxide_cd "$1"
    elif [[ ${@: -1} == "${__zoxide_z_prefix}"?* ]]; then
        # shellcheck disable=SC2124
        \builtin local result="${@: -1}"
        __zoxide_cd "${result:${#__zoxide_z_prefix}}"
    else
        \builtin local result
        # Allow for leading '--' in args from autocd etc. See issue #776
        while [[ $1 == '--' ]]; do \builtin shift; done
        # shellcheck disable=SC2312
        result="$(\command zoxide query --exclude "$(__zoxide_pwd)" -- "$@")" &&
            __zoxide_cd "${result}"
    fiinit
}

This is just the normal __zoxide_z function as generated by zoxide init, with one line of code (and one comment) to strip the leading -- from the arguments, since one is hardcoded and more is broken. This one is for bash, so you might need to adjust it to work with your shell of choice. I'll be happy to help if you're stuck :)

I would submit this as a PR, but I'm brand new around here and have no idea if this is the 'right way' to do it for this project.... But this works just fine, for now :)

pallaswept avatar Apr 19 '24 01:04 pallaswept

Not just the autocd but sometimes other tools change directory for you and they do it in a way that's not covered by zoxide. A good solution is to watch when current directory PWD changes which is a hook that's provided by most shells, if not, there must be a hook that runs whenever the prompt is changed and then you can run $(pwd) to get the current dir and compare it.

anasouardini avatar Apr 20 '24 11:04 anasouardini

they do it in a way that's not covered by zoxide.

If it isn't the prepended -- that is reported by OP and I, you might want to log a separate case, but, specify it, and I'll see what I can do :)

pallaswept avatar Apr 20 '24 15:04 pallaswept

Same here with my md function :(

❯ which md

md () {
        [[ $# == 1 ]] && mkdir -p -- "$1" && cd -- "$1"
}
❯ md Test
zoxide: no match found

I updated it in my dotfiles to force it to use my builtin shell command instead.

❯ md () {
    [[ $# == 1 ]] && mkdir -p -- "$1" && builtin cd -- "$1"
}
❯ md Test
❯ pwd
/home/waser/Test

wasertech avatar May 30 '24 16:05 wasertech

#695 almost resolves this, so maybe this issue can be closed now...

Although... Not that I care a lot, but there is a bug in that fix - it will work with the autocd command, but if someone attempts to use cd with the -- option, along with another argument, then it will not trigger that new rule, because there will be more than two arguments.

/home/pallaswept> cd -P -- /tmp
zoxide: no match found

/home/pallaswept> builtin cd -P -- /tmp

/tmp> 

My workaround above has a similar bug.

Perhaps a more robust way to do this, is to check that the second-to-last argument is the -- string, since the last arg is the target directory, and any other options supplied would always be prior to the --.

pallaswept avatar Jun 25 '24 19:06 pallaswept

Fixed in https://github.com/ajeetdsouza/zoxide/pull/695.

ajeetdsouza avatar Sep 12 '24 19:09 ajeetdsouza