source-han-serif icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
source-han-serif copied to clipboard

Inconsistent strokes for components containing 睪 (JP only)

Open Marcus98T opened this issue 1 year ago • 1 comments

The 幸 part in 睾 (U+777E), 睪 (U+776A) and 殬 (U+6BAC) is not consistent with the other characters containing 幸 for JP and KR, instead following the CN style where the bottommost stroke is longer than the second-most bottom stroke.

Screenshot 2023-02-24 at 17 21 03

This is also a problem in Kozuka Mincho and other Japanese fonts that try to follow the Adobe-Japan1 standard closely.

Screenshot 2023-02-24 at 17 22 19

From left to right: Kozuka Mincho, Hiragino Mincho (which got the component consistent, marked in green), Toppan Bunkyu Mincho and YuMincho.

Therefore, new JP glyphs for 睾 and 睪 would be needed (for JP and KR, marked in yellow), whereas the current ones will be mapped to CN, TW and HK.

Screenshot 2023-02-24 at 17 19 09

The ones in cyan are outside Adobe-Japan1-6 (following the CN forms), although the sole character in blue (鸅, U+9E05) is a non-Adobe-Japan1 JP glyph that should have been removed in v2.

Source Han Sans JP is fine.

EDIT: Restore v1 JP for 殬 (U+6BAC) instead. See here.

Marcus98T avatar Feb 24 '23 09:02 Marcus98T