source-han-sans icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
source-han-sans copied to clipboard

Issue with U+5EB7(康)

Open KathrynCG opened this issue 2 years ago • 7 comments

图片 left: TW; right: HK The glyph of TW and HK should be the same. I think the glyph of TW should be deleted, and map it to HK. 图片

And, there are more similar problems of 氺。

KathrynCG avatar Jan 09 '23 13:01 KathrynCG

Another one with the same issue is U+57ED. 57EDTW-HK

punchcutter avatar Sep 15 '23 04:09 punchcutter

Another HK/TW issue with the 隶 component is U+96B8. HK and TW are almost identical, but that's because the TW glyph is wrong. The 示 component should be TW style with no hook.

96B8-compare

punchcutter avatar Sep 15 '23 04:09 punchcutter

We can drop the TW glyphs for U+5EB7 and U+57ED and fix the TW glyph for U+96B8.

punchcutter avatar Sep 15 '23 04:09 punchcutter

image

You may also want to add uni5ADD-TW and uni6177-TW to the list of removal.

tamcy avatar Sep 15 '23 05:09 tamcy

These might use some look too: U+9C47鱇 U+5F54彔 U+6641晁 (using JP) U+525D剝 U+9F17鼗 (using JP) U+50A3 傣 IMG_20230915_141359.jpg

NightFurySL2001 avatar Sep 15 '23 06:09 NightFurySL2001

@NightFurySL2001's post is expanding the characters with component 隶 to those with 氺 and 兆. But I think it's better to handle 兆 separately (隶 can be loosely considered as ⿻肀氺, but 兆 has nothing to do with 氺). I mean, if it really needs fixing, which I don't think so.

Anyway, for the component 氺, there are actually more glyphs involved:

(1) For 彔 (i.e. ⿱彑氺), uni5F54-TW and uni908D-TW can be removed; the corresponding HK glyphs can be used for TW.

image image

(2) There's one more component that also has a 氺 in it, which is 暴 (⿳日共氺). There is no glyph to remove, but several remapping suggestions:

image image

No. Codepoint Character Region Current Suggested
1 U+5124 TW uni5124-CN uni5124-JP
2 U+5697 TW uni5697-CN uni5697-HK
3 U+61EA TW uni61EA-CN uni61EA-HK
4 U+66DD HK and TW uni66DD-CN uni66DD-JP
5 U+7011 TW uni7011-CN uni7011-JP

Dot-separated design aligns better with the current dedicated glyphs, like image and image.

Finally, if we also count 求 which is somtimes rendered as ⿻一氺 (like, when placed on the left), I have 3 proposed changes (1 glyph dropping, 1 remapping, and 1 redesign). Not sure if this should also be listed here tough, but this should be the last component involved with 氺 😅

tamcy avatar Sep 15 '23 08:09 tamcy