EmpiricalStandards

EmpiricalStandards copied to clipboard

Supplementary materials heading added

Devbimpe

The systematic review standard should be divided into at least three standards for meta-analysis, case survey, critical review, meta-synthesis. Somewhere we need to explain that ad hoc reviews, rapid reviews...

drpaulralph

In definition? Title? What's the best way to do this?

drpaulralph

Clarify that structured interviews are methodologically equivalent to questionnaire surveys.

drpaulralph

organize essential attributes into IMRaD groups

9

As a checklist user, I want the essential attributes to be organized by where they typically appear in papers rather than by the standard they're drawn from So I don't...

drpaulralph

https://openreview.net/ has an open API, which might be easier to work with than HotCRP or Easychair.

drpaulralph

Method selection decision tree

3

Create a flow chart or decision tree to help users determine which standard(s) to select. (Suggestions welcome).

drpaulralph

missing artifact standards

2

timm

clean up the bibliography entries for the suggested readings and exemplars, and put them all in ACM style.

1

@drpaulralph says: Please clean up the bibliography entries for the suggested readings and exemplars, and put them all in ACM style. But the refs seem fine to me.

timm

Create a "standard" for novel or other methods

2

We need some kind of recommendations for reviewing a method for which there is no existing standard, such that a reviewer can click "other" in the reviewer checklist generator and...

drpaulralph