RandLA-Net-pytorch icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
RandLA-Net-pytorch copied to clipboard

Better accuracy with smaller block in S3DIS

Open josegemez opened this issue 3 years ago • 18 comments

Hi, I have implemented this repository with custom S3DIS data (xyz and normal only) I had tried with entire rooms, and blocks (5x5, 2x2, and 1x1)... The best accuracy I have got is with the smallest block... Is it possible that local encoder not work properly? It can related with the square distances? Thanks in advance. 2022_09_28@8-53

josegemez avatar Sep 28 '22 07:09 josegemez

I had got some improvements... I had mix some code from:

https://github.com/isl-org/Open3D-ML/tree/master/ml3d/torch/models image

josegemez avatar Oct 13 '22 07:10 josegemez

More improvements... I have tweaked dropout in the last mlp and the batch normalization parameters...

image

josegemez avatar Oct 15 '22 20:10 josegemez

Thank you very much. i also find that the net cannot learn the features.....May be I should learn something from OPEN3D.

Dlemand avatar Oct 19 '22 03:10 Dlemand

Hi @josegemez, I tried similar improvements with Open3D's code, even though the baseline results were better, but still I am only getting good scores for classes with larger point clouds only while inputting whole room as input. Except for few classes, for most of the other classes the model is learning nothing.

Could you please provide more specific details on the exact input samples during the training and your code improvements from the Open3D-ML's implementation. It would be really helpful, thanks in advance!

ashishrana160796 avatar Nov 25 '22 16:11 ashishrana160796

@josegemez Is it convenient to open source your code? I used the code of openml to merge and there is still no good result, thank you

KiKuBoy avatar Jan 02 '23 12:01 KiKuBoy

@xiaoxina12 同学你好,你能跑通这个代码吗,我这边一直遇到各种bug

jscksy avatar Jan 09 '23 09:01 jscksy

2023-01-09 17-19-28屏幕截图 可以跑通,但是根本学不到特征,我又对照其他各个版本改了下,还是很难收敛。

KiKuBoy avatar Jan 09 '23 09:01 KiKuBoy

同学能开源或者发到我邮箱[email protected]吗,非常感谢?我刚入门,一路debug还是没跑通 image

jscksy avatar Jan 09 '23 09:01 jscksy

@jscksy 可以的,等晚上吧,我的代码也没有收敛,期待你可以把它收敛。

KiKuBoy avatar Jan 09 '23 09:01 KiKuBoy

@jscksy 可以的,等晚上吧,我的代码也没有收敛,期待你可以把它收敛。

能加个好友吗,我改了一份代码是哪个自动驾驶版本的,也是遇到了问题,想发一份给你一起交流我的微信shendaln

SC-shendazt avatar Feb 08 '23 13:02 SC-shendazt

可以啊,我后面跑出来的也挺奇怪的,我的邮箱 @.***

------------------ 原始邮件 ------------------ 发件人: "aRI0U/RandLA-Net-pytorch" @.>; 发送时间: 2023年2月8日(星期三) 晚上9:29 @.>; @.@.>; 主题: Re: [aRI0U/RandLA-Net-pytorch] Better accuracy with smaller block in S3DIS (Issue #42)

@jscksy 可以的,等晚上吧,我的代码也没有收敛,期待你可以把它收敛。

能加个好友吗,我改了一份代码是哪个自动驾驶版本的,也是遇到了问题,想发一份给你一起交流

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

jscksy avatar Feb 08 '23 15:02 jscksy

@jscksy 可以的,等晚上吧,我的代码也没有收敛,期待你可以把它收敛。

同学你好,请问可以发我一份代码吗,我最近也在复现这个,遇到很多bug,我的邮箱是[email protected],万分感谢

Xuelangshuo avatar Mar 18 '23 14:03 Xuelangshuo

2023-01-09 17-19-28屏幕截图 可以跑通,但是根本学不到特征,我又对照其他各个版本改了下,还是很难收敛。

好兄弟,你的代码能分享给我一份吗,我的结果还没你的高,我的邮箱是:[email protected]

wangzihao77 avatar Apr 14 '23 07:04 wangzihao77

@josegemez 好兄弟,可以分享一份你改进的代码吗,我复现出的结果也是挺糟糕的,我的邮箱是:[email protected]

wangzihao77 avatar Apr 14 '23 07:04 wangzihao77

2023-01-09 17-19-28屏幕截图 可以跑通,但是根本学不到特征,我又对照其他各个版本改了下,还是很难收敛。

你好,可以分享下你的代码吗?

wangzihao77 avatar May 10 '23 09:05 wangzihao77

@josegemez Dear josegemez, may you help me provide your modified code. Very bad results were gotten when using this code. Could you please help me, this is my email: [email protected] And thank you very much

didiwei60 avatar Jul 02 '23 06:07 didiwei60

2023-01-09 17-19-28屏幕截图 可以跑通,但是根本学不到特征,我又对照其他各个版本改了下,还是很难收敛。

可以发我一份代码吗,我的邮箱[email protected]

667825a avatar Nov 22 '23 07:11 667825a

同学能开源或者发到我邮箱[email protected]吗,非常感谢?我刚入门,一路debug还是没跑通 image

我也出现这个问题了,最后怎么解决的呢

667825a avatar Nov 22 '23 07:11 667825a