YARG icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
YARG copied to clipboard

Some Vocal Charts have desync of lyrics.

Open Crono141 opened this issue 1 year ago • 9 comments

Some songs start with the vocal chart desynced, sometimes by several seconds/phrases.

The song I was first able to note this on was "I Ran" By a Flock of Seaguls. In rock band proper there are tamborine hits before the first vocal phrase, but these are absent in YARG. Instead, just before the vocals come it, YARG pops an "Awesome" (as if you had hit all the tamborine hits), and then the rest of the chart is desynced by some amount. Its significant, like half a vocal phrase desynced.

I thought the tamborine hits was the cause, but the other track I had issues with is Bad Moon Rising by CCR which doesn't exhibit this behavior. The rest of the band are in sync on these tracks, only the vocals are off. I tried both tracks in both Stable and Nightly, and confirmed that the RB3 versions I have (which is derived from the same source as the YARG copies) does not exhibit this behavior.

Crono141 avatar Dec 26 '23 23:12 Crono141

Thanks for the report! Yes, the "Awesome"s that popup for the vocal solos are known, because they haven't been implemented yet, and count as perfect, so future scores aren't effected. As for the de-sync, I played the song you mentioned, but there were no issues. Do you have any settings changed that could cause this?

EliteAsian123 avatar Dec 26 '23 23:12 EliteAsian123

Not that I know of. I could provide the pack/midi file if you like to see if you can replicate. If it's a bad midi file I can try and mess with it to fix it on my end, but I wanted to rule out any import problems as a cause first.

Crono141 avatar Dec 27 '23 00:12 Crono141

Here's the CCR song for testing purposes. THe other one is too large to attach. Creedence Clearwater Revival - Bad Moon Rising.7z.zip

Crono141 avatar Jan 04 '24 19:01 Crono141

@Crono141 Are you still able to reproduce this issue? Might be useful to have your settings/profile for testing if so.

TheNathannator avatar Feb 08 '24 06:02 TheNathannator

I will check it this weekend. Had some stuff come up at home that takes priority but I might have some time sunday. Haven't checked since v0.12 merged to stable.

Crono141 avatar Feb 08 '24 12:02 Crono141

Awesome, thanks in advance!

I took some time to add everything from here and inside our Discord onto our other issue tracker, this is one of the few things left to add if it still happens.

TheNathannator avatar Feb 08 '24 12:02 TheNathannator

@Crono141 Any update on this?

RileyTheFox avatar Feb 20 '24 07:02 RileyTheFox

Sorry guys. Didn't mean to flake out. Have had some stuff come up in the real world that I had to deal with, and this slipped my mind. I'll try and get something out to you this week, though. IS there an easy way to export settings/profile so I can include it when I do update?

Crono141 avatar Feb 21 '24 15:02 Crono141

OK, I did check again and this song attached still has probably 1-2 seconds mismatch between vocals heard and vocals charted.

Crono141 avatar Feb 24 '24 22:02 Crono141