XcodesApp icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
XcodesApp copied to clipboard

Support Logging in with Federated Apple ID

Open testableapple opened this issue 2 years ago • 9 comments

Describe the bug

  • Unable to download Xcode without authorization Screen Shot 2023-01-03 at 7 47 36 PM

  • Unable to log in with Federated Apple ID Screen Shot 2023-01-03 at 7 48 26 PM

Expected behavior

or

  • Xcode can be downloaded without authorization

Version

  • macOS: 12.5.1 (21G83)
  • Xcodes: 1.9.0

testableapple avatar Jan 03 '23 19:01 testableapple

Currently facing the same issue. With a business-managed account we are not able to download new xcodes version since we can't authenticate. Any idea how to solve that ? thanks!

dazigna avatar Jan 25 '23 16:01 dazigna

@dazigna @alteral Hi!

Currently we don't support logging in through Federated Authentication. I don't have any way to see how it works, as I'm not part of any federated organization.

Can you can easily create your own personal apple id instead?

MattKiazyk avatar Feb 03 '23 03:02 MattKiazyk

Hi @MattKiazyk Thanks for the quick answer, This is what I ended up doing. Federated Authentication is some kind of Oauth but tbf I do not know how this works under the hood.

dazigna avatar Feb 03 '23 06:02 dazigna

Hi @MattKiazyk, thanks for your suggestion, this is what I ended up doing too.

Isn't it possible to allow downloading xcodes without authorisation?

testableapple avatar Feb 03 '23 16:02 testableapple

@alteral that is correct at the moment. There was a brief moment this past year where we could get a token that allowed downloading without logging in, however Apple returns 403 forbidden now on those calls.

I would love to have a way to not log in, or at least use an App-Specific password, but I haven't figured out how yet.

MattKiazyk avatar Feb 03 '23 16:02 MattKiazyk

Gotcha. Ok, thanks 👍

testableapple avatar Feb 03 '23 17:02 testableapple

You can also download using http://xcodereleases.com instead of apple via the XcodesApp

Mcrich23 avatar Feb 13 '23 02:02 Mcrich23

@Mcrich23 I'm getting the same error message that tells me I need to log in with my Apple ID regardless of whether I have xcodereleases.com or Apple selected as my Downloads data source, so unfortunately that doesn't seem to resolve the Federated Apple ID issue.

davidpasztor avatar Apr 11 '23 10:04 davidpasztor