GS SC-88Pro drumkits instruments 0-26 and 89-127 are silent

[freq-mod]

Happens to libOPNMIDI too (bank will be OPN2 as well, but whatever). gs.tar.gz - midi and bank

I have a huge problem with percussion instruments beyond 87 (open surdo). The midi in question uses these, but couldn't find them, reporting " - Debug: [10] Playing missing instrument 104" among others. So can add it. It should be in SC-88Pro Standard Set 1 I guess, so I did just that. What happened? Still the same message. The only way to hear these drums is to add them into GM1 Standard drums set, which isn't correct.

So, am I doing something wrong?

[Wohlstand]

What the bank number should be required? I mean include the minor bank number too

[freq-mod]

I don't know. SMF-DSP reports MIDI ch11, Acoustic Guitar (steel) and GM1 Percussion, so yeah... I don't know how to check it.

[Wohlstand]

The base off 0

[freq-mod]

oh I see

[Wohlstand]

:eyes:

[freq-mod]

sorry for bothering, but... somehow it still persists - I forgot to remove instr 104 from GM1 set, but after doing that (and putting it into the correct set, it doesnt play them Why you shouldn't hurry - reason no. 2612

[freq-mod]

Still I don't know whether drum no. 104 in this midi should be Snare 3 or Phono Noise, it depends from the bank

[Wohlstand]

Will need to check some later

[freq-mod]

I checked - it must be a Phono Noise and Hip Hop GS drumset. So the problem is with non-GM percussive instruments of indexes 0-27 and 89-127 being silent/not even recognized. MSB doesn't matter it seems :thinking:

[Wohlstand]

Closing as abandoned. If really needed something, please give a note.