MineKhan icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
MineKhan copied to clipboard

Vertical slabs

Open SuperNova841 opened this issue 3 years ago • 10 comments

My friend multibuilder just asked me to request this :D

SuperNova841 avatar Sep 17 '21 22:09 SuperNova841

Willard probably won't add that

ghost avatar Sep 17 '21 23:09 ghost

I wouldn't mind adding it. But I can't think of a user-friendly way to place them without breaking existing mechanics. Like, if you place a slab against a wall, you expect it to either place a top slab or a bottom slab, depending on which half of the block you placed it on. You don't expect it to place sideways. If you propose a solution to this that I like then I'll add it to my to-do list.

Willard21 avatar Sep 17 '21 23:09 Willard21

Maybe horizontal and vertical slabs could just have separate inventory shapes?

SuperNova841 avatar Sep 18 '21 20:09 SuperNova841

Only do sideways placement while shift is pressed? Then it can be only one item but have two behaviors

Oranamous avatar Sep 18 '21 22:09 Oranamous

Making shift place sideways slabs would make it impossible to bridge with slabs.

Making them separate blocks/shapes could work, though it seems a little silly to have 2 shapes that are the exact same, but rotated. It could work though.

Willard21 avatar Sep 18 '21 23:09 Willard21

Maybe do what I said just now but reversed? Then you could have normal behavior when you press shift, but default to use side placement

Oranamous avatar Sep 19 '21 18:09 Oranamous

or a menu pops up for selection?

magic4792 avatar Oct 04 '21 21:10 magic4792

actually, Thingmaker made logs that can be placed normally, or on the side of things, so that could be useful(although i personally am against the idea, just like Mojang is)

RedMonster2 avatar Oct 15 '21 16:10 RedMonster2

H O R I Z O N T A L S T A I R S Dramatization (cuz i cant think of the word but let me be it's 10:43 PM rn):

Screenshot 2021-10-31 10 42 37 PM

ImaginaryNeon avatar Nov 01 '21 03:11 ImaginaryNeon

Yeah... He was suggesting a block of that shape.

Willard21 avatar Nov 02 '21 23:11 Willard21

that's not real, you just made 2 4x4 cubes and left 2 blocks out of the stone stairs

  1. I can't mod the game while in williard.fun/minekhan
  2. It's obvious due to the grass textures.

ImaginaryNeon avatar Nov 03 '21 12:11 ImaginaryNeon

also, horizontal stairs, are not actually in minecraft

RedMonster2 avatar Nov 03 '21 14:11 RedMonster2

Yeah, I know. But I want them. Now give me your money. This is a robbery.

ImaginaryNeon avatar Nov 03 '21 18:11 ImaginaryNeon