Baileys icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Baileys copied to clipboard

[BUG] buttons and lists stopped working

Open filipeloose opened this issue 1 year ago • 42 comments

filipeloose avatar May 10 '23 03:05 filipeloose

Yes, after the latest update on Android today, list and button messages didn't show up on the receiver.

batarabagus avatar May 10 '23 04:05 batarabagus

same issue

Kawasan-Opensource avatar May 10 '23 05:05 Kawasan-Opensource

Same with me any Solution ?

No solution for now, but to appear on wa web you can still add the viewOnce parameter

makanSukros avatar May 10 '23 06:05 makanSukros

Same Issue

vishwajit76 avatar May 10 '23 06:05 vishwajit76

it's a sign that it's time for you to change lib:v hehehe

arskyy avatar May 10 '23 06:05 arskyy

it's a sign that it's time for you to change lib:v hehehe

It's not about this lib, but indeed at this time WhatsApp has an update and some are missing, I tried other libs and got the same thing, it's good that we try to solve this problem together

makanSukros avatar May 10 '23 07:05 makanSukros

It's not about this lib, but indeed at this time WhatsApp has an update and some are missing, I tried other libs and got the same thing, it's good that we try to solve this problem together

right bro the problem is not in the lib... there may be an update on the whatsapp server not on the client

lambangwi avatar May 10 '23 07:05 lambangwi

itu tandanya sudah saatnya kalian ganti lib:v hehehe

🐒

KiZakiXD avatar May 10 '23 07:05 KiZakiXD

Rip Baileys?

KiZakiXD avatar May 10 '23 07:05 KiZakiXD

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

hmcorpltd avatar May 10 '23 08:05 hmcorpltd

2, 2228, 8

Not work on ios

makanSukros avatar May 10 '23 08:05 makanSukros

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

wati working /:

MaznAbdullah avatar May 10 '23 08:05 MaznAbdullah

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

image btw this using official API. work mobile and web

lambangwi avatar May 10 '23 08:05 lambangwi

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

image btw this using official API. work mobile and web

api kok ditanya

KiZakiXD avatar May 10 '23 08:05 KiZakiXD

I have just checked that now i am not getting response to list messages from the bank who are using official api. Seems this bug is temporary.

image btw this using official API. work mobile and web

api kok ditanya

kamu hengker yah

arskyy avatar May 10 '23 09:05 arskyy

FYI, the maintainer have decided to put button feature as deprecated feature. The deprecation will be done in the future. This means the button will not be fixed anymore. It's time to say goodbye to the button feature from the library.

Fonnte avatar May 10 '23 23:05 Fonnte

After 5 votes from Contributors, Mods, and even Pedro himself, I've decided to begin the process of deleting Buttons and Lists. The patch that I released a few days ago was either under wraps or not widely applied for a long time (2 months) and the same day I posted it here it has been patched internally by WhatsApp. This timing is very fishy and to not irritate Meta even more, I drew this line. If you're a business, and you profit a lot from every conversion you make, you can go ahead and use the official Meta API for all I care. I've been working discreetly with other library leaders for about 50 hours total all together reverse engineering to figure this out (whatsmeowlead, whatsappweb4j, baileys, openwa and wppconnect) and after all our efforts nothing has worked out. This is what we really end up with in the end because depending on solution after solution whatever you build on top of it will fail. Like building a hospital on bamboo scaffolding. It takes a heavy heart to say this, I know. I also have a mountain of code to change now (Hypere, StormChat, and countless other partners and clients over the years). Open-wa, Baileys, whatsapp-web.js, and wppconnect will be deprecated keys. The process is slightly different for each library but in the end it will all be the same. - purpshell, maintainer of whatsapp-web.js and Baileys for 3 years now (in case you didn't know)

arskyy avatar May 10 '23 23:05 arskyy

RIP #Buttons #List :(

lambangwi avatar May 11 '23 00:05 lambangwi

2, 2228, 8

Not work on ios Im worked on Ios and Web using "version": [2, 2228, 8]

8d566099-c18b-43dc-ba2b-6322d24d6488

screenshot 118

In IOS Still working

sembilan-d avatar May 11 '23 03:05 sembilan-d

So I'm gonna have a look today. Still even if i fix it, at this point you really shouldn't be relying on buttons.

Auties00 avatar May 11 '23 09:05 Auties00

same issue

hosamalzagh avatar May 11 '23 13:05 hosamalzagh

Same with me any Solution ?

No solution for now, but to appear on wa web you can still add the viewOnce parameter

yeah, the button can still be seen on your 'whatsapp web' but it's not sent to your mobile device... this issue hasn't been fixed for so long

codemakesense07 avatar May 13 '23 08:05 codemakesense07

After 5 votes from Contributors, Mods, and even Pedro himself, I've decided to begin the process of deleting Buttons and Lists. The patch that I released a few days ago was either under wraps or not widely applied for a long time (2 months) and the same day I posted it here it has been patched internally by WhatsApp. This timing is very fishy and to not irritate Meta even more, I drew this line. If you're a business, and you profit a lot from every conversion you make, you can go ahead and use the official Meta API for all I care. I've been working discreetly with other library leaders for about 50 hours total all together reverse engineering to figure this out (whatsmeowlead, whatsappweb4j, baileys, openwa and wppconnect) and after all our efforts nothing has worked out. This is what we really end up with in the end because depending on solution after solution whatever you build on top of it will fail. Like building a hospital on bamboo scaffolding. It takes a heavy heart to say this, I know. I also have a mountain of code to change now (Hypere, StormChat, and countless other partners and clients over the years). Open-wa, Baileys, whatsapp-web.js, and wppconnect will be deprecated keys. The process is slightly different for each library but in the end it will all be the same. - purpshell, maintainer of whatsapp-web.js and Baileys for 3 years now (in case you didn't know)

hi @arskyy and teams, thanks for everything that you guys have done until this far. may i know, other than button and list, what else that dev will deprecate (other than on server side)? just precautions. thanks

reski-rukmantiyo avatar May 13 '23 16:05 reski-rukmantiyo

I forgot to reply, but there's a server side filter now. So the issue cannot be solved. Btw only buttons, list and template are getting deprecated

Auties00 avatar May 13 '23 16:05 Auties00

I forgot to be reply, but there's a server side filter now. So the issue cannot be solved. Btw only buttons, list and template are getting deprecated

thanks @Auties00 for clarifications.

reski-rukmantiyo avatar May 13 '23 17:05 reski-rukmantiyo

Rip Baileys?

stfu

bentacos avatar May 13 '23 17:05 bentacos

+1

marcelo386 avatar May 14 '23 23:05 marcelo386

Is it the end of the list for API free?

fernandomirassol avatar May 15 '23 17:05 fernandomirassol

It seems that if we downgrade the library version, the message button will work again, right?

satriowicaksn avatar May 16 '23 04:05 satriowicaksn

It seems that if we downgrade the library version, the message button will work again, right?

on older(2 Months ago) versions of Whatsapp yes

Auties00 avatar May 16 '23 06:05 Auties00