Proton icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Proton copied to clipboard

Wreckfest (228380)

Open mimattr opened this issue 6 years ago • 72 comments

Ubuntu 16.04, NVIDIA GTX 970, Proton 3.7-4 Beta:

Steam System Information

Test Result
Singleplayer Working as expected
Local Co-op N/A
Online Multiplayer Partially working^
Configuration ...
Input Steam Controller
Display 1920x1080
Fullscreen Yes
Preset Medium^^
VSync Off
API DX11

^ Using Server Browser causes application freeze ^^ Default graphics preset is Custom

mimattr avatar Aug 27 '18 15:08 mimattr

Ubuntu 18.04, Nvidia GTX 780Ti, Proton 3.7-4 Beta:

Steam System Information

Test Result
Singleplayer Working as expected
Local Co-op Did not test
Online Multiplayer Causes Wine to crash on selecting a match
Configuration ...
Input Xbox 360 controller
Controller works? Yes

I would have added a proton log of the Wine crash, but this log is 1.1 gigabytes in size. So uploading that would not be very convenient.

HonkingGoose avatar Aug 28 '18 20:08 HonkingGoose

Ubuntu 18.04.1 LTS (64 bit), Geforce GTX 970, Proton 3.7-6 Beta:

Steam System Information

Test Result
Starting the game in 32-bit mode  Steam loads the game for a while, then stops
Starting the game in 64-bit mode  Steam loads the game for a while, then stops

Error log

xtrom0rt avatar Sep 16 '18 13:09 xtrom0rt

Whitelist Request

  • Name of the game to be whitelisted: Wreckfest
  • Steam AppID of the game: 228380

System Information

I confirm:

  • [x] that pressing the Play button in the Steam client is sufficient.
  • [ ] that runtime config options are necessary to run the game.
  • [ ] that no workarounds other than PROTON_* env variables are necessary.

Issues

  • [x] I haven't experienced any issues.
  • [ ] There are no issues left open for this game.
  • [ ] Although I consider the gaming experience equal to Windows there are remaining issues.

mimattr avatar Dec 28 '18 16:12 mimattr

Is anyone seeing an issue with this game and Proton 3.16-6 that would block it from being whitelisted?

kisak-valve avatar Dec 28 '18 17:12 kisak-valve

Hi @kisak-valve.

What works now that didn't before:

  • I was able to connect to a online multiplayer game now on Proton 3.16-6, whereas the game would crash out on trying to connect to a match on Proton 3.7-4 Beta.

Issue that might prevent whitelisting:

  • The Proton/Wine wrapper crashes when exiting the game from the main menu. I need to manually shutdown the wine wrapper. The Gnome desktop session keeps running normally.

I'm running Ubuntu 18.10 now, with Nvidia 410.78 drivers. I'm not sure if the Proton log actually has the crash of the wrapper?

Gist: https://gist.github.com/HonkingGoose/32f5d065a2ea8d6d43024c9749cbb28c Proton log 3.16-6: steam-228380.log

I'm a unsure of what's the recommended Nvidia driver branch nowadays for Proton. The 415 branch seems to have Vulkan things in it, the 396 branch is some kind of beta branch and 410 is mainline. So I'm getting confused as to what is the Nvidia driver branch I should be using to test things...

HonkingGoose avatar Dec 28 '18 19:12 HonkingGoose

@kisak-valve

For me single player works with no issues in Wreckfest. But multiplayer does not.

It does open the server browser and populates the list, but then crashes when I click on any of the servers. I am on the other hand able to create a LAN server and start a game with bots with no issues.

Proton log: steam-228380.log

thepanu avatar Jan 15 '19 21:01 thepanu

Hello @thepanu, your log has ...SteamLibrary/steamapps/common/Proton 3.7... which I read as Proton 3.7-8. Please retest with Proton 3.16-6.

kisak-valve avatar Jan 15 '19 22:01 kisak-valve

@kisak-valve Thanks. That helped. Now it works. I think that I had a thinking error on my part "obviously 3.7-8 is newer than 3.16-6 as I had that version selected in the settings.

thepanu avatar Jan 16 '19 17:01 thepanu

Switched to a whitelist request. For AMD gpu users, this game requires mesa 18.3.5 or newer for https://bugs.freedesktop.org/show_bug.cgi?id=109597.

kisak-valve avatar Feb 22 '19 14:02 kisak-valve

Game will not start for me. I get the initial configuration screen and then a screen which says "Loading" for about a minute and then it just crashes out.

Log file : steam-228380.log

Technomancer2 avatar Mar 24 '19 13:03 Technomancer2

Hello @Technomancer2, please copy your system information from Steam (Steam -> Help -> System Information) and put it in a gist, then include a link to the gist in this issue report.

kisak-valve avatar Mar 24 '19 13:03 kisak-valve

Here is the gist https://gist.github.com/Technomancer2/2297e9ac7d311f9c241eb014b1bcf5da

Technomancer2 avatar Mar 24 '19 14:03 Technomancer2

Anyone else unable to join multiplayer races? I get into the lobby, but setting myself ready does not ready me up. It holds that light green colour text colour and not full green. It works on windows.

BieHDC avatar Aug 30 '19 09:08 BieHDC

Anyone else unable to join multiplayer races?

@BieHDC Online multiplayer appears to work as expected (tested with Quick Match and Server Browser), can you add PROTON_LOG=1 %command% to the game's launch options and drag and drop the generated $HOME/steam-228380.log into your issue report, danke.

System Information

mimattr avatar Aug 31 '19 15:08 mimattr

I found a problem with my Logitech G29 wheel. If I use the last version of Proton (4.11-6) the game works but the wheel is not correctly calibrated. In the central position the wheel is turned to the right. When you test the wheel in configuration you can see taht something goes wrong. In adittion to that Force Feedback don't work. If I downgrade Proton to 4.2-9, everything works ok, the wheel is calibrated correctly and FFB works great. I think this is a very clear regression

steam-228380.log

leillo1975 avatar Sep 27 '19 19:09 leillo1975

Wreckfest crashes with full system freeze

Issue transferred from https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/issues/3192. @mroote posted on 2019-11-05T01:08:38:

Compatibility Report

  • Name of the game with compatibility issues: Wreckfest
  • Steam AppID of the game: 228380

System Information

  • GPU: GTX 1060
  • Driver/LLVM version: 435.21
  • Kernel version: 5.3.8-arch1-1
  • Link to full system information report as Gist: https://gist.github.com/mroote/1b47f9a6d3c624204453de5819062db2
  • Proton version: 4.11-7

I confirm:

  • [ X ] that I haven't found an existing compatibility report for this game.
  • [ X ] that I have checked whether there are updates for my system available.

Symptoms

The game will completely freeze my desktop with no ability to alt-tab or make any actions on the system like switch window sessions. I can only recover with a reboot to get back to the normal desktop.

The only error I can see being logged in the system logs are regarding a fault with the video card but I haven't found anything else that seems to stand out as causing this issue.

Nov 04 19:10:07 ghost kernel: NVRM: Xid (PCI:0000:01:00): 31, pid=647, Ch 00000043, intr 10000000. MMU Fault: ENGINE GRAPHICS GPCCLIENT_T1_4 faulted @ 0x5fff_55b17000. Fault is of type FAULT_PDE ACCESS_TYPE_READ

kisak-valve avatar Nov 05 '19 01:11 kisak-valve

I found a problem with my Logitech G29 wheel. If I use the last version of Proton (4.11-6) the game works but the wheel is not correctly calibrated. In the central position the wheel is turned to the right. When you test the wheel in configuration you can see taht something goes wrong. In adittion to that Force Feedback don't work. If I downgrade Proton to 4.2-9, everything works ok, the wheel is calibrated correctly and FFB works great. I think this is a very clear regression

steam-228380.log

New version of Proton (4.11-8) stills breaking Force Feedback in this and a lot of racing games. Other games like: -Project Cars 2 -Project Cars 1 -GT Legends -RACE 07

https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/issues/3194

leillo1975 avatar Nov 08 '19 23:11 leillo1975

Just an update for https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/issues/758#issuecomment-549619246. I seem to have resolved this issue by uninstalling the game and reinstalling. Must be some kind of corruption issue but reinstalling seems to have worked as it has not frozen for a few sessions now.

mroote avatar Nov 09 '19 19:11 mroote

Game does not start for me, I have tried:

  • Steam Linux Runtime - Error: error occured while updating Wreckfest (invalid app configuration)
  • Proton 4.11-9 (32bit, 64bit, 64bit w/o mods) - game doesn't start steam-228380.log for 64bit
  • Proton 4.2-9 (32bit, 64bit, 64bit w/o mods) - Error: no available graphics adapter(s) found
  • Proton 3.16-9 (32bit, 64bit, 64bit w/o mods) - Error: no available graphics adapter(s) found
  • Proton 3.7-8 (32bit, 64bit, 64bit w/o mods) - Error: no available graphics adapter(s) found

System Info

  • Full info gist
  • OS: Ubuntu 18.04.3 LTS
  • KERNEL: 5.0.0-36-generic
  • CPU: Intel Core i5-2500K @ 3.30GHz
  • GPU: AMD BONAIRE (R7 260x)
  • GPU DRIVER: 4.5 Mesa 19.1.2 - padoka PPA
  • RAM: 16 GB

penguinpowernz avatar Nov 30 '19 05:11 penguinpowernz

Hello @penguinpowernz, you have a Sea Islands (CIK) generation AMD card, and Linux uses the radeon kernel module by default with this generation. The radeon kernel module is not compatible with Vulkan. Please give https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/wiki/For-AMD-users-having-issues-with-non-OpenGL-games a read.

kisak-valve avatar Nov 30 '19 12:11 kisak-valve

Thank you @kisak-valve it works great now, even multiplayer and PS3 sixaxis controller.

penguinpowernz avatar Nov 30 '19 13:11 penguinpowernz

I found a problem with my Logitech G29 wheel. If I use the last version of Proton (4.11-6) the game works but the wheel is not correctly calibrated. In the central position the wheel is turned to the right. When you test the wheel in configuration you can see taht something goes wrong. In adittion to that Force Feedback don't work. If I downgrade Proton to 4.2-9, everything works ok, the wheel is calibrated correctly and FFB works great. I think this is a very clear regression

steam-228380.log

The same problem stills on 4.11-9. If total degrees are a segment, the center is in 80% of this segment instead of 50%.

leillo1975 avatar Dec 09 '19 21:12 leillo1975

Just noticed Wreckfest now has only a quarter of the speed it used to run at. In Windows I can run it at 100fps+ on Ultra, while in Linux it now only runs at 20-30fps, I used to get close to Windows fps, not sure when this happened as I've been wrapped up in work.

True for both fedora (5.3.16 kernel, 440 nvidia) and Ubuntu (5.4.5 kernel, 440 nvidia). Other games I run with Proton work swell still.

Update: Have tried with either/both ESYNC and FSYNC disabled. Tried 32bit. Various versions of Proton including GE. The difference between Windows and Proton on the same settings preset (Ultra) and a demolition derby with 24 cars is 100fps on Windows vs 15fps on Proton.

Visually the game looks perfect. Just runs ultra slow on ultra. I must not have noticed earlier because I was running it on high with free-sync monitor so it felt smooth. I only recently decided to compare performance vs Windows.

Update2: Changing resolution to lower doesn't help. Seems to have same FPS limits. Performance is related to what's on screen for example all 24 cars == ~20fps, do a U-turn and fps goes to 30-40fps.. Still a far cry from Windows performance. Decreasing graphics options gains fps, but still, it would be good to get the same performance level at the same graphics levels.

flukejones avatar Dec 21 '19 03:12 flukejones

Performance seems lower for me also, though i didn't even know it since i don't use Windows. i'm getting 55-60 FPS when all 24 cars are in view at the start of the race, but actual racing its usually 90-120 FPS... it sounds good on paper, but looking at the windows perf in youtube it seems like ~2x worse perf:

Example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xP6tsC82kAA

Now i have GTX 1080Ti (440.43.01), Ryzen 3700X and kernel 5.4.2 pds+fsync I also run similar settings as in this video. 2560x1440 all maxed, except i have MSAA 4x and FXAA off. He only has GTX 1070Ti there and a i7 6700K. Rest is same

Ofc we cannot hope to get windows perf, but at least 80-90% of the perf shouldn't be a issue i think.

Ofc i don't complain, cause i can enjoy the game with pretty OK framerates, but its seems its still nowhere where it should be.

xpander69 avatar Dec 22 '19 10:12 xpander69

Anyone else having issues getting controllers working again? PS4 controller used to work without isses but now I can't get the game to recognize it. Steam does find and it works in other games.

thepanu avatar Dec 25 '19 21:12 thepanu

I found a problem with my Logitech G29 wheel. If I use the last version of Proton (4.11-6) the game works but the wheel is not correctly calibrated. In the central position the wheel is turned to the right. When you test the wheel in configuration you can see taht something goes wrong. In adittion to that Force Feedback don't work. If I downgrade Proton to 4.2-9, everything works ok, the wheel is calibrated correctly and FFB works great. I think this is a very clear regression steam-228380.log

The same problem stills on 4.11-9. If total degrees are a segment, the center is in 80% of this segment instead of 50%.

With Proton 5.0-2 this problem is not corrected. To play this game is nedded to use Proton 4.2-9

leillo1975 avatar Feb 13 '20 21:02 leillo1975

Still appalling performance in Proton. Windows still averages 100fps with all 24 cars in view, at Ultra settings, while I get 25-30fps in Proton.

flukejones avatar Mar 18 '20 07:03 flukejones

Anyone else having issues getting controllers working again? PS4 controller used to work without isses but now I can't get the game to recognize it. Steam does find and it works in other games.

I'm having the same issue. It doesn't seem to recognize my PS4 controller though it works in other Proton games. I tried changing the controller to be a generic xbox in the steam settings but none of the changes seemed to make a difference in detecting the controller.

mroote avatar Mar 27 '20 23:03 mroote

Nvidia drivers 440.66.07 (beta) which includes fixes for Doom: Eternal:

Added a workaround for Linux Steam Play title DOOM Eternal, which overrides application requested memory locations, to ensure performance-critical resources be placed in video memory [Linux]

boosted performance in Wreckfest by maybe double. It's still half of what I get in Windows with:

  • 24 cars on screen
  • Ultra settings
  • Fairfield demolition

I also have an issue where if I don't have g-sync enabled, then the steam overlay FPS counter seems to show a cap of half my max refresh rate (50 for 100hz screen), and it never seems to dip below 33fps. G-sync enabled appears to allow higher fps, and also never dips below 33fps. Because of this I'm quite uncertain of the actual impact or fps accuracy, but the game is feeling very smooth.

The difference between 30fps in my previous comment and the 33fps in this comment is extremely noticeable. I couldn't even hint at what may be happening here.

flukejones avatar Apr 02 '20 01:04 flukejones

Just compared with Windows again with the above details and I get ~77fps in Windows fairly consistently with GPU@100% and CPU@~90%, while Linux fluctuates between 30-60fps with GPU@100% and CPU@~50%,

flukejones avatar Apr 02 '20 03:04 flukejones