Shift+o doesn't respect indentation setting (when using Autoindent)

[fschoenm]

Describe the bug My indentation is set to spaces. When using o to add a new line below the cursor, it starts indented with spaces but when pressing O (Shift+o) to add a line above the cursor, it sometimes uses tabs instead.

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1. Open a new file in VS Code, set indentation to spaces, enable "Vim: Autoindent", and use the following text:

def test():

····print("test")

····return

2. Go to line 3.
3. If I press o, a new line begins below the cursor and inserts spaces:

def test():

····print("test")
····|

····return

4. If I press Shift+o instead, a new line begins above the cursor and inserts tabs:

def test():

→   |
····print("test")

····return

Expected behavior Respect the indentation setting in all cases.

Screenshots

Environment (please complete the following information):

• Extension (VsCodeVim) version: v1.26.0
• VSCode version: v1.83.0
• OS: Windows 10

Additional context n/a

[seantwie03]

I don't think I am able to reproduce this on 1.26.2.

If I use Shift+o it seems to do the behavior you suggest, but it is hard to say because the way VSCode deletes indentation. For example, if you open a new line, press space 8 times, then press backspace it will delete 4 spaces (depending on your settings). So it simulates deleting a 'tabwidth' even if you just typed in spaces.

[wmstack]

If I am on a closing brace, and type shift-o it doesn't create the indentation for the code block just above. This is also true anywhere on the line where the closing brace is.