NoiseModelling icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
NoiseModelling copied to clipboard

Propagation error in NM 4.0.5??

Open IsotoCedex opened this issue 1 year ago • 7 comments

A/A @pierromond, as we have spoken:

NoiseModelling version 4.0.5

Describe the bug When executing the calculation, part of the roads are ignored

Calculation of 2 consecutive roads in NM 4.0.5

image

Same calculation in 4.0.4

image

Source Data: SourceData.zip

Process: Process.txt

Results: Results_raster.zip

IsotoCedex avatar Nov 17 '23 12:11 IsotoCedex

Hello

I tried and I got the two roads source

image

Maybe re-download NoiseModelling 4.0.5 there was an issue the first few days of the release and the release zip was fixed the 29 sept.

nicolas-f avatar Nov 17 '23 13:11 nicolas-f

Did you used regular grid reveivers 10x10 m?

Can you share your process?

IsotoCedex avatar Nov 17 '23 13:11 IsotoCedex

Did you used regular grid reveivers 10x10 m?

I used 200m*200m

Can you share your process?

I've loaded your process, the changes is I use original dem.

nicolas-f avatar Nov 17 '23 13:11 nicolas-f

Please, can you repeat with 10x10 regular grid? I did twice, with the same result.

IsotoCedex avatar Nov 17 '23 13:11 IsotoCedex

Did you download again NoiseModelling 4.0.5 ?

The sha256 of the zip file should be 1adf4a2a13a63a6b5d65fa0930054e1ae4b6934babc21aa63d8d4e98aa1928cd

nicolas-f avatar Nov 17 '23 13:11 nicolas-f

Yes. I downloaded It. I have used the last file.

IsotoCedex avatar Nov 17 '23 13:11 IsotoCedex

Hi @nicolas-f

I've been testing.

The problem occurs when I enrich DEM with "Enrch DEM with road".

I have detected several problems:

  • POS_SOL field is mandatory in road layer.
  • WIDTH field is not taken into account. Go to https://github.com/Universite-Gustave-Eiffel/NoiseModelling/discussions/633
  • Some roads are ignored.

It has nothing to do with the density of the receiver.

Enriched DEM: DEM_25M_10K_ROAD_DRAP_WIDTH.zip Roads file: Road_drap.zip Original DEM: DEM_25M_10K.zip

Related to: https://github.com/Universite-Gustave-Eiffel/NoiseModelling/issues/615

image

image

IsotoCedex avatar Nov 19 '23 17:11 IsotoCedex