OpenGothic icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OpenGothic copied to clipboard

Cannot Jump-Climb to edge from standing position with free space at front

Open Abendlied opened this issue 1 year ago • 8 comments

Game: Gothic I & Gothic II NotR

Short Description/Observation: Cannot jump-climb to an edge on top of the player from standing position if there is room to jump forward. Game will always default to forward-jump instead of climb-jump.

Steps to reproduce: position player under a climbable edge with still some space in front of the player (not standing directly with the face touching the wall)

Additional information Savegame for Gothic 1: save_slot_14.sav.tar.gz Video (3 sec, 1.3 MiB): https://github.com/Try/OpenGothic/assets/86957596/b31b9dcd-dc82-4b73-a7de-4a40840dfd27 More videos: climb1 climb2

Savegame for Gothic 2 NotR:
save_slot_11.sav.tar.gz

related to but not really covered by #312

edit: added G2 savegame, applies to G1 and G2NotR

Abendlied avatar May 24 '24 20:05 Abendlied

Is this Gothic I specific? I think the issue is similarly present in G2.

Nindaleth avatar May 25 '24 13:05 Nindaleth

@Nindaleth you are right, it applies to G2 as well. Savegame for Gothic 2 NotR:
save_slot_11.sav.tar.gz

Abendlied avatar May 26 '24 22:05 Abendlied

playercontrol.cpp has conditions jumping from standing position:

else if(pl.isStanding()) { auto jump = pl.tryJump(); if(!pl.isFalling() && !pl.isSlide() && jump.anim!=Npc::Anim::Jump){ pl.startClimb(jump); return; } ani = Npc::Anim::Jump; } else { ani = Npc::Anim::Jump;

could we change the condition defaulting to startClimb first and only if that does not work, try jump?

Abendlied avatar Aug 01 '24 16:08 Abendlied

Added videos, from #666, to description

Try avatar Aug 14 '24 19:08 Try

Hi, @Try. How are you? Do you have any plans to fix this issue in the near future? I'm playing Gothic again and I've encountered this bug again. Could you please try to fix this issue, because it's a bit inconvenient to play with.

YALdysse avatar Mar 01 '25 16:03 YALdysse

Any news ?

YALdysse avatar Jun 25 '25 06:06 YALdysse

HI @YALdysse !

Unfortunately no updates yet

Try avatar Jun 25 '25 16:06 Try

Hi, @Try. Is there any news about this issue? Thanks.

YALdysse avatar Sep 07 '25 07:09 YALdysse