GestureSign icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
GestureSign copied to clipboard

Tip-tap gesture support

Open chanibal opened this issue 5 years ago • 14 comments

Hi, I'm moving from MacOS and BetterTouchTool, and I'm missing one type of gestures - the tip taps.

There, I could do a gesture like this: first I hold down finger one and then I tap finger two on the left or right. I can do this many times and alternate between left and right tip taps (I have to keep the first finger down during that duration)

In my case, I used this gesture as a nice way to switch application tabs (in windows this would be a ctrl+pgup/pgdown shortcut).

Is there any way to set this up? If not, I'd like to request this feature.

chanibal avatar Jul 23 '19 14:07 chanibal

I need tip-tap support too!

pbuzdin avatar Aug 29 '19 16:08 pbuzdin

You can sort of emulate tip taps by fiddling with the finger id trigger in the advanced section of the gestures. Ex: id_1 < id_2 means that the leftmost finger needs to touch before the next right finger does. Unfortunately both need to end with touching the screen at the same time

lukewma avatar Dec 17 '19 12:12 lukewma

Tip tap feature would be awesome.

@lukewma I can't find the advanced section of the gestures, to try out your workaround. Can you point me at the right direction?

umutucler avatar Jul 01 '20 12:07 umutucler

@lyscop, sorry but I have no idea on how to set this up, as you recommend.

The tip tap gesture should work as follows:

Tip-tap left:

   O  O     start touching or hold
 . . .
O  O  O     add third finger

Tip-tap right:

O  O       start touching or hold
 . . .
O  O  O    add third finger

chanibal avatar Nov 02 '20 17:11 chanibal

@lyscop, sorry but I have no idea on how to set this up, as you recommend.

The tip tap gesture should work as follows:

Tip-tap left:

   O  O     start touching or hold
 . . .
O  O  O     add third finger

Tip-tap right:

O  O       start touching or hold
 . . .
O  O  O    add third finger

Sorry, l mislead it, it seems the current vision can not achieve tip-tap function.

What I said are double click two or three fingers.

lyscop avatar Nov 04 '20 12:11 lyscop

try this.

pg up down tiptap.zip

motfis avatar Nov 04 '20 15:11 motfis

Hello, I tried to use this, but was not able to. I imported properly, got the shortcuts in the "(Global actions)" section, but simply cannot tap to generate the action.

chanibal avatar Nov 05 '20 23:11 chanibal

Hello, I tried to use this, but was not able to. I imported properly, got the shortcuts in the "(Global actions)" section, but simply cannot tap to generate the action.

SmartSelect_20201106-074401_Gallery hmm... I am not sure why it does not work in your case. works well for me. Do you use trackpad? Did you try to enable "precision trackpad"? maybe driver issue?

motfis avatar Nov 06 '20 06:11 motfis

I have recorded the said gesture (two finger fix variant) using BetterTouchTool (MacOS). I'm trying to use the same gesture using GestureSign.

@motfis: Driver error? It is possible. Macbook 2015's touchpad is not registered as a precision touchpad. To do that, I use an unofficial driver: Windows Precision Touchpad Implementation for Apple MacBook family/Magic Trackpad 2. How can I check if this is the case? Perhaps some kind of event recording in GestureSign?

chanibal avatar Nov 07 '20 18:11 chanibal

I tried on touchpad. Indeed, it does not work on touchpad. It seems that gesture sign always registers touch as "Finger 1". Unfortunately I don't know how to trace the touch event. I think only the author can answer it (or someone with more knowledge on this code).

motfis avatar Nov 13 '20 22:11 motfis

I tried on touchpad. Indeed, it does not work on touchpad. It seems that gesture sign always registers touch as "Finger 1". Unfortunately I don't know how to trace the touch event. I think only the author can answer it (or someone with more knowledge on this code).

It seems just normal test on screen, but the touchpad can realize how many finger on it, and can not find out what the finger is, so tip tap do not work well on touchpad by set the trigger.

lyscop avatar Nov 15 '20 15:11 lyscop

To emulate BTT's tip tap on touchpad, I use a tipswipe like gesture with swipe to bottom (see on screenshot). It is obviously not the same, but feels similar enough. Zrzut ekranu 2021-01-31 164430

wadimw avatar Jan 31 '21 15:01 wadimw

I second this request. While the "workaround" by wadimw isn't bad, it would be great, if it could be exactly the same as in BetterTouchTool.

therobbot avatar Nov 07 '22 20:11 therobbot

+1

cros13 avatar Jan 26 '23 20:01 cros13