Yanick Witschi

Yes, that's a pity then. The user made a mistake. It's better to have an exception on that page than wrong content? In worst case content from a protected page...

Ok, put in other words. I prefer the exception. If you don't want it to throw an exception then I think it's better to replace the InsertTag with no content...

> So actually, /sitemap.xml should be a route that returns the appropriate sitemap depending on the domain. Yes. That's something we should have by default. Makes no sense to enable...

Yeah, it can be generated on demand but obviously not every time it is requested. So I'd still cache it somewhere in `/cache/contao/sitemaps` or so (with `sitemap_.xml` maybe?) and just...

@leofeyer can you move that to contao/core-bundle please? Because it's not going to change for Contao 3.5 anyway but would be a super nice addition to any future Contao 4...

Talked to @frontendschlampe about it, maybe they'll be working on a PR :)

If it is a route, we do not mess with it at all :) It's sort of fallback. If you upload a `robots.txt` apache (or whatever server) will take this...

Google recommends to split them up (did not check how exactly) and I'm sure there's some recommendation on the threshold somewhere :)

I don't think it's correct for voters to check on request attributes. What should be voted on and what not is defined by the attributes, not any scope.

It‘s marked as up for discussion.