C-Plus-Plus icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
C-Plus-Plus copied to clipboard

Many abandoned PRs

Open Panquesito7 opened this issue 5 years ago • 11 comments

There are about 10 pages of open PRs without any comments, reviews or labels. Shall we review those PRs, close them, or something else that you propose?

Panquesito7 avatar Jun 29 '20 19:06 Panquesito7

@Panquesito7 i was also thinking about this, some of the PR's are very old and no one is likely to response over them, i think PR's which are older than 2 Months should be closed. @kvedala what's your opinion on this ?

ayaankhan98 avatar Jun 29 '20 22:06 ayaankhan98

Once in a while, I go to the old commits and have requested the authors for status. I think every author should get a chance to revive their contribution and if they do not respond for a maximum of 2 weeks, the pull-request should be marked "abandoned" and closed. Open for suggestions and to check how such issues are being addressed in the other repos of TheAlgorithms group. - @AnupKumarPanwar

kvedala avatar Jun 29 '20 22:06 kvedala

pull-request should be marked "abandoned"

The Stale app can help with this. 🙂

Panquesito7 avatar Jun 29 '20 22:06 Panquesito7

Once in a while, I go to the old commits and have requested the authors for status. I think every author should get a chance to revive their contribution and if they do not respond for a maximum of 2 weeks, the pull-request should be marked "abandoned" and closed. Open for suggestions and to check how such issues are being addressed in the other repos of TheAlgorithms group. - @AnupKumarPanwar

okay let's ping the authors of the old PR, see if they response then it's nice else we will mark them "abandoned"

ayaankhan98 avatar Jun 29 '20 22:06 ayaankhan98

Once in a while, I go to the old commits and have requested the authors for status. I think every author should get a chance to revive their contribution and if they do not respond for a maximum of 2 weeks, the pull-request should be marked "abandoned" and closed. Open for suggestions and to check how such issues are being addressed in the other repos of TheAlgorithms group. - @AnupKumarPanwar

okay let's ping the authors of the old PR, see if they response then it's nice else we will mark them "abandoned"

If someone has already messaged, it is pointless to post yet another message in the PR. Please check before posting. Thank you

kvedala avatar Jun 29 '20 22:06 kvedala

Very much agree - even closed PRs are quite easy to re-open if the author comes back.

fhlasek avatar Oct 11 '20 05:10 fhlasek

Hello everyone,

I am not sure who the main author of this repository is, but I have a project of working on open source code and was wondering which of the issues here are still open. Most of them have comments that say people are working on them. I was wondering if there were a couple open issues I could help address? @Panquesito7

ghost avatar Nov 10 '20 16:11 ghost

Hello everyone,

I am not sure who the main author of this repository is, but I have a project of working on open source code and was wondering which of the issues here are still open. Most of them have comments that say people are working on them. I was wondering if there were a couple open issues I could help address? @Panquesito7

Unless an issue is closed, it is very likely that it is un-resolved and anybody can contribute per the repo guidelines. Feel free to pick any such open issue and contribute. Thank you.

kvedala avatar Nov 26 '20 11:11 kvedala

This issue has been automatically marked as abandoned because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

stale[bot] avatar Feb 13 '21 20:02 stale[bot]

Please ping one of the maintainers once you add more information and updates here. If this is not the case and you need some help, feel free to ask for help in our Gitter channel. Thank you for your contributions!

stale[bot] avatar Mar 20 '21 05:03 stale[bot]

There are many awaiting PRs that opened on this repo. Why do the maintainers not look at these PRs or give suggestions to make these PRs better and ready to merge? Instead of abandoning these PRs and taking a bot to automatically assign stale labels on these PRs, try to have a look at them to decide which PR should be reviewed or merged.

sozelfist avatar Apr 28 '24 03:04 sozelfist