System.IO.Abstractions icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
System.IO.Abstractions copied to clipboard

Incorrect LastAccessTime & LastWriteTime for directory

Open CzBuCHi opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

Describe the bug Mock file system is not storing LastAccessTime & LastWriteTime properties for directories

To Reproduce

var fileSystem = new MockFileSystem();
var info = fileSystem.DirectoryInfo.FromDirectoryName(@"C:\\Parent\\Dir");
info.Create();
info.LastWriteTime = new DateTime(2001, 2, 3);

var c= fileSystem.DirectoryInfo.FromDirectoryName("C:\\Parent");
foreach (var info in parent.EnumerateDirectories()) {
   var thisShouldBeTrue = info.LastAccessTime  == new DateTime(2001, 2, 3);
}

Expected behavior variable thisShouldBeTrue should be true.

Additional context class MockFileSystem should have method AddDirectory(string path, MockDirectoryInfo mock) so i can set directory attributes same way as in method AddFile. MockDirectoryInfo is derived from MockFileInfo but with no content (only default ctor) and with attribute FileAttributes.Directory.

CzBuCHi avatar Apr 29 '22 15:04 CzBuCHi

Sounds useful, maybe @siprbaum you also have an opinion here 😀

fgreinacher avatar May 06 '22 15:05 fgreinacher

First, let me adress thispart:

Additional context class MockFileSystem should have method AddDirectory(string path, MockDirectoryInfo mock) so i can set directory attributes same way as in method AddFile. MockDirectoryInfo is derived from MockFileInfo but with no content (only default ctor) and with attribute FileAttributes.Directory.

I think you meant MockDirectoryInfo -> MockDirectoryData and MockFileInfo -> MockFileData. Adding a method

AddDirectory(string path, MockDirectoryData mock)
                          ^^^^ ...Data not ...Info

could be useful, I believe.

Concerning the automatic LastAccessTime update when enumerating the directroy:

var fileSystem = new MockFileSystem();
var info = fileSystem.DirectoryInfo.FromDirectoryName(@"C:\\Parent\\Dir");
info.Create();
info.LastWriteTime = new DateTime(2001, 2, 3);

var c= fileSystem.DirectoryInfo.FromDirectoryName("C:\\Parent");
foreach (var info in parent.EnumerateDirectories()) {
   var thisShouldBeTrue = info.LastAccessTime  == new DateTime(2001, 2, 3);
}

Expected behavior variable thisShouldBeTrue should be true.

Isn't this also depending on the underlying OS, e.g Linux vs Windows if and when the xxxTimes are updated? But I have to admit I haven't looked to deeply into it.

So at least this second part sounds more controversial than the first part to me.

siprbaum avatar May 06 '22 16:05 siprbaum