OoT-Randomizer icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OoT-Randomizer copied to clipboard

Got Gerudo Mask instead of item

Open r0bd0g opened this issue 7 years ago • 11 comments

LuckE Today at 3:22 AM https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/313327428703485953/508902050466365450/unknown.png

got gerudo mask instead of small key in shadow temple CR2ARSBKMPAAYZN4HA8A - settings string with the hot swap boots version

r0bd0g avatar Nov 05 '18 15:11 r0bd0g

"Seed information is I the picture. Item location was the chest in the room that opens after you collect the silver rupees in the room with the spinning blades of death."

(It's a coop seed.)

r0bd0g avatar Nov 05 '18 15:11 r0bd0g

I'm sorry this happened, but I think it's really funny

phixtyseven avatar Nov 06 '18 11:11 phixtyseven

I'm unsure what would cause this, however there has since been a refactor of the get item code to be a lot more reliable. Also this bug report is a dead link, so any kind of reproducability would be pretty impossible

TestRunnerSRL avatar Jan 22 '19 18:01 TestRunnerSRL

This apparently is still happening?

pidgezero_one Today at 3:03 PM world 1 gohma prize drop model was a triforce piece, i picked it up and it gave me a gerudo mask

r0bd0g avatar Jan 02 '21 21:01 r0bd0g

This apparently is still happening?

pidgezero_one Today at 3:03 PM world 1 gohma prize drop model was a triforce piece, i picked it up and it gave me a gerudo mask

This was the seed in question:

https://ootrandomizer.com/seed/get?id=668302

Was using the Dec. 7 merge of the multiworld repo master branch

pidgezero-one avatar Jan 03 '21 04:01 pidgezero-one

This issue should not have been closed. It still occurs even today. I think all reports of it have been from MW seeds? Apparently the fix is to repatch the ROM? So the going theory is that it's some kind of rare error in the patching process. (But some people say that resetting and picking the item up again, it works fine, no need to repatch.)

r0bd0g avatar May 07 '22 06:05 r0bd0g

Got another instance of this in https://ootrandomizer.com/seed/get?id=1266725. Player 3 found a Gerudo mask instead of a Triforce piece from Gerudo Training Ground Heavy Block First Chest.

fenhl avatar Nov 28 '22 20:11 fenhl

The player reports that when resetting and opening the chest again, the item became a Triforce piece.

fenhl avatar Nov 28 '22 20:11 fenhl

They all seem to be Triforce Pieces. 1-2 years ago I played a MW and someone also got this bug when the model was a Triforce Piece (crater wall freestanding item). Iirc they didn't have to repatch, but just quit (without saving) and pick up the item again.

ETR-BTF avatar Jun 19 '23 08:06 ETR-BTF

So it's likely only Triforce pieces in multiworld now and doesn't happen anymore for other items or in singleplayer. But it obviously doesn't happen every time, we've had a few Triforce Hunt seeds in S4 and no reports of this yet. It's also most likely a bug in the randomizer, as it has been happening both to bizhawk-co-op users (e.g. the report from @pidgezero-one) and to Mido's House Multiworld users (e.g. the report I posted).

If anyone has any ideas on where this could be coming from or has noticed something else the occurrences of this bug have in common, please post a comment.

fenhl avatar Jan 25 '24 18:01 fenhl

Now that trade quest shuffle is a thing, we may want to introduce a dedicated “error” item or use an item that's unused in vanilla instead of using the Gerudo mask, because right now players running into this issue may not even realize it.

fenhl avatar Jan 25 '24 18:01 fenhl