REPENTOGON icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
REPENTOGON copied to clipboard

[Bug] Make Dream Catcher work with Greed mode

Open nyabinary opened this issue 1 year ago • 5 comments
trafficstars

This is a pretty rare but annoying vanilla bug that maybe Repentogon can fix?

nyabinary avatar Aug 02 '24 00:08 nyabinary

This is simply not a bug, its a feature request of something that was never implemented into the vanilla game. Not sure it falls on scope for repentogon to do as, again, we have no way of knowing how the item should have worked in greedmode even.

jsgnextortex avatar Aug 02 '24 14:08 jsgnextortex

Counterargument:

  1. Dream Catcher is available in Greed mode, it appears in the shop pool: image
  2. It shows the treasure room contents during the floor transition: image
  3. The shown items are wrong: image

Therefore, it is a vanilla bug that the item gives the wrong information despite being available in the greed mode. A fix would be to either make it show accurate information or to outright disable the floor transition dream sequence (the item is not useless even without that gimmick, it still gives half a soul heart on every new floor)

im-tem avatar Aug 02 '24 14:08 im-tem

It is easy to dismiss the issue but the fact is that item is still very misleading and it's not wrong to think that it showing outright wrong items is a bug.

im-tem avatar Aug 02 '24 14:08 im-tem

This bug was apparently fixed in patch that never went live? https://github.com/UnderscoreKilburn/repentance-issues/issues/155

im-tem avatar Aug 02 '24 14:08 im-tem

It displaying the wrong item or it appearing in greed mod could be considered a bug, but the item functionality also involves displaying bosses which is what my reasoning was in regards to dismissing the thing as a "bug", as the feature to display bosses, which is part of the raw functionality of the item, is not implemented for greed mode at all and, in my head, "making the item work", would involve displaying the bosses correctly.

jsgnextortex avatar Aug 02 '24 15:08 jsgnextortex