ext-solr icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ext-solr copied to clipboard

Published 20 hours ago • verified publisher icon TYPO3-Solr

[BUG] Subpage of page with restricted access and extendToSubpages set is removed from index queue

Open timhorstmann opened this issue 1 year ago • 7 comments

Scenario:

  • rootpage
    • page A (with restricted access, fe_group is selected and extendToSubpages is set)
      • page B (without any access restrictions set)

When the index queue is build for the first time, both pages A+B get indexed and can be found (with proper FE access rights). If page B gets updated, it is instantly removed from index queue and also from solr index and therefore can not be found anymore.

There seems to be no way to get page B indexed again than rebuilding the index queue. But with any update to page B it is removed again, so this can not be valid workaround.

I investigated a little and found the responsible lines of code:

In FrontendEnvironment/Tsfe.php the necessary usergroups are fetched only from the current site. These groups are later used for building a tsfe and checking the access to the page. This fails in the described scenario with a page-not-found-response.

This bug is a variation of Issue 3271, although the problem here might be solved easier. From my point of view it should be sufficient to collect the usergroups from the rootline until rootpage or a page with extendToSubpages set.

Used versions:

TYPO3 Version: 11.5.25 Browser: firefox EXT:solr Version: 11.5.1 Used Apache Solr Version: 8.11.1 PHP Version: 8.1 MariaDB: 10.5

timhorstmann avatar Mar 30 '23 12:03 timhorstmann

If this bug can be confirmed and the described solution is valid, I could try to fix it.

timhorstmann avatar Mar 30 '23 12:03 timhorstmann

@timhorstmann the 3563 seems to be wrong in description. Please change it to the right one.

dkd-kaehm avatar Mar 30 '23 15:03 dkd-kaehm

Yes, it did never work.

dkd-kaehm avatar Mar 30 '23 15:03 dkd-kaehm

@timhorstmann the 3563 seems to be wrong in description. Please change it to the right one.

You're right, I updated to 3271

timhorstmann avatar Mar 30 '23 21:03 timhorstmann

We confirm this bug in EXT:solr Version: 11.5.5 & TYPO3 11.5.33. Any updates on this issue?

DavRet avatar Dec 04 '23 14:12 DavRet

I run into similiar issues but I don't get page B to be indexed - no matter if on 1st run or later on :(

georgringer avatar Dec 20 '23 09:12 georgringer

I run into similiar issues but I don't get page B to be indexed - no matter if on 1st run or later on :(

I guess not a run, but initializing the index queue for pages.

dkd-kaehm avatar Dec 20 '23 09:12 dkd-kaehm