dicio-android icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
dicio-android copied to clipboard

Icon Dicio

Open MXC48-zz opened this issue 2 years ago • 12 comments

I think Dicio's icon is way too simplistic (no offense to whoever made it), Dicio is a voice assistant, so its icon should inspire usability. I tried to make an icon that would better fit the project, I started with the idea that when people see the icon, they should know right away that it's a voice assistant, or at least that it has something to do with voice. Please tell me what you think about it and if it fits, you can use it as you want.

MXC48-zz avatar Apr 18 '22 19:04 MXC48-zz

the circle that surrounds the microphone, for me is thick. but I got the idea.

Cristian19194848 avatar Apr 23 '22 20:04 Cristian19194848

the circle that surrounds the microphone, for me is thick. but I got the idea.

icon_Dicio-new_20220422180151.jpg I had another idea for an icon

MXC48-zz avatar Apr 28 '22 12:04 MXC48-zz

Thank you for taking some time to improve Dicio's look! I am not sure if I like those icons. In my opinion they are too colorful and they miss specific references to "Dicio". I prepared a few alternatives but I am not sure I like those, too:

Stypox avatar Apr 28 '22 16:04 Stypox

I don't know much about designing icons, but here are some basic ideas I had: image

However, I feel these are way too busy for an app icon, specially since other popular voice assistants' icons are basically just circles:

imagen

For future reference for anyone who tries to contribute, @Stypox where did you get the "D" in the icon from? Is it a font?

Elaborendum avatar May 02 '22 16:05 Elaborendum

@Elaborendum thank you for creating those icons! I agree they are a little bit too busy, but I think the bottom-right one actually looks fine.

For future reference for anyone who tries to contribute, @Stypox where did you get the "D" in the icon from? Is it a font?

I built it manually using Krita, I uploaded it in the repository a couple of days ago: https://github.com/Stypox/dicio-android/blob/master/meta/logo.kra

Stypox avatar May 02 '22 19:05 Stypox

I just tried another one to try icon Well, it's more a concept than a finished icon

MXC48-zz avatar May 04 '22 15:05 MXC48-zz

@MXC48, modify your previous response if you want to add anything after you post it to avoid spam.

RokeJulianLockhart avatar May 04 '22 15:05 RokeJulianLockhart

@MXC48, the contrast within "https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/82712837/166714129-e4aa6179-7a7e-4226-b207-b8b649d58634.svg" is too minor to be able to ascertain what symbolism is within the yellow bubbles, and does not fit within the circular, or more uncommonly, square crop that the Google Play Store and most launchers necessitate. However, with some reorganisation, I believe that I would like it. Additionally, I am glad that it is vectoral.

RokeJulianLockhart avatar May 04 '22 15:05 RokeJulianLockhart

@MXC48, modify your previous response if you want to add anything after you post it to avoid spam.

Sorry, I'll do it right away

MXC48-zz avatar May 04 '22 15:05 MXC48-zz

I like this as a proof of concept, since the logo is still there and the bubbles make me think "this app can do many things", which is great. However, the additional icons should not clutter the image and not make the D too small.

Here I improved the colors a little ;-) a

Stypox avatar May 05 '22 22:05 Stypox

Here I improved the colors a little ;-)

Yes with your color it's already much better, I didn't have the colors on hand but I think it's an idea to look into further 😁

MXC48-zz avatar May 06 '22 10:05 MXC48-zz

Screenshot_20221002_093916 I'm in favor of this or similar variation of microphone within D

sybenx avatar Oct 02 '22 15:10 sybenx

What do you think of this? Which one is better? I uploaded the files I used to generate them to the meta/ folder

Drop shadow Cast shadow

Stypox avatar Oct 27 '22 09:10 Stypox

I personally prefer the Drop shadow icon.

matchboxbananasynergy avatar Dec 26 '22 01:12 matchboxbananasynergy

I don't mind the Cast Shadow one, but I think the area in the microphone icon cutout is too dark. If you combined the two that way (cast shadow outside, drop shadow inside), it might look better.

OkyDooky avatar Dec 30 '22 03:12 OkyDooky

Imo the one with the shadow doesn't match the modern android icons and looks dated. This used to be nice in the past.

Turbolqk avatar Dec 30 '22 07:12 Turbolqk

Let it be "Drop shadow" then. Thanks for sharing your opinion and thanks to everyone involved in this discussion! See 42e3c9fcd2064a8efe2858dec9c4794ff5bb619f

Stypox avatar Dec 31 '22 10:12 Stypox