bubbles icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
bubbles copied to clipboard

Darn

Open bencharb opened this issue 8 years ago • 5 comments

This seemed to be the most complete Python ETL package. Why don't Python nerds need to ETL?

bencharb avatar May 14 '16 02:05 bencharb

Yup, seems to be dead... :/

robinkeunen avatar Jun 22 '16 13:06 robinkeunen

😞

emmanuellyautomated avatar Nov 21 '17 17:11 emmanuellyautomated

Why don't Python nerds need to ETL?

Maybe they have custom solutions, like me. The most important thing is parallelism, jobs scheduling and execution, a possibility to track issues (inspecting a staging state step-by-step), scheduler state inspection and management, and so on. Abstraction layer for transforms/calculations aren't so important, because they can be done in raw sql. For everyting else, i.e matrix operations, a numpy/scipy packages are just enough. Just my 5cents.

marcinn avatar Nov 21 '17 17:11 marcinn

@marcinn what do you use for the more important points that you mentioned? Something like Luigi?

rjendoubi avatar Dec 24 '17 10:12 rjendoubi

I didn't know about Luigi when I was starting work with ETLs. I created something similar to this, but way limited - without dependency handling, parallelism only within a run() method, just sequence of tasks per job, simple jobs scheduler and runner (2in1, just 1 runner at once).

My ETL was a simple Python script written in one module, at the beginning. It was changing slowly into something bigger, and that's how my custom library and scheduler was created.

Luigi looks more powerful and generic. I think I'll start using it, because maintaining a custom solution isn't cheap and requires a lot of time. Thank you for pointing Luigi here.

marcinn avatar Dec 25 '17 06:12 marcinn