stellarium icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
stellarium copied to clipboard

More features for Observability Analysis

Open alex-w opened this issue 7 years ago • 10 comments

Original report by Keatah: https://bugs.launchpad.net/stellarium/+bug/1045297

Observability Analysis plugin (ideas for more features)

Things to add to the plugin:

  • [x] Distance from Sun for Solar System objects
  • [x] Heliocentric x,y,z distances
  • [x] More info for phases of the moon - Age, Angular Size.
  • [ ] Some sort of graphical popup moon calendar
  • [ ] Degree of subtention
  • [x] Some sort of general astronomy calculator (this could be another plug-in or a totally different application entirely)

alex-w avatar Sep 26 '18 06:09 alex-w

Some of the numbers should be given only when accuracy issues have been solved. Else people would start using Stellarium as reference solution...

gzotti avatar Sep 26 '18 09:09 gzotti

Maybe overkill, but a dialog could be shown that warns the user about the accuracy of the graphs, or some other way to indicate that accuracy is not good for reference use? Just freewheeling: how about making the lines thicker, as fine lines imply high accuracy?

axd1967 avatar Oct 19 '19 09:10 axd1967

@axd1967 Do you want to confirm a dialog for every numerical result that is technically wrong in the last displayed decimal figure? You will hurt your index finger from clicking.

Appendix F in the Stellarium User Guide is where you find accuracy estimates. As long as the version number is 0.*, you should not use Stellarium as reference source for numerical ephemerides.

gzotti avatar Oct 20 '19 21:10 gzotti

No... I was thinking about a one-time dialog with a checkbox that allows the user to hide it "forever" (or until reset by some other means). The dialog could contain one or more hyperlinks to one of these:

  • https://github.com/Stellarium/stellarium/blob/master/guide/app_accuracy.tex,
  • https://github.com/Stellarium/stellarium/blob/1dbadaec8e50a1cfdc681cfa99f8bc3dbf79414e/guide/app_accuracy.tex#L10-L30
  • https://github.com/Stellarium/stellarium/releases/download/v0.19.2/stellarium_user_guide-0.19.2-1.pdf.

axd1967 avatar Oct 20 '19 21:10 axd1967

I made such a one-time warning for users with too old computers that they should expect graphic problems. Those still reported about graphics problems. "Ah yes, there was some warning, but I clicked continue". Do you think anybody cares for what they confirmed when accepting some popup dialog that you see once just after installation or at first run?

gzotti avatar Oct 20 '19 22:10 gzotti

Couple features are implemented in main code already:

  • [x] Distance from Sun for Solar System objects
  • [x] More info for phases of the moon - Age, Angular Size.

Plus one feature is implemented in debug mode:

  • [x] Heliocentric x,y,z distances

Probably we may add it in the release mode too, but... how it really necessary?

alex-w avatar Nov 13 '20 06:11 alex-w

What is "Degree of subtention" in astronomical application?

alex-w avatar Nov 13 '20 06:11 alex-w

I mark last item as solved due AstroCalc tool

alex-w avatar Jun 09 '22 14:06 alex-w