solid-ui
solid-ui copied to clipboard
Form: Add default properties for a new object?
When using ui:Multiple
, currently a new object is created and linked to the subject with the specified ui:property
.
https://github.com/solid/solid-ui/blob/c4ad302f361cc4a1de24941a475cb66333c43805/src/widgets/forms.js#L273
The form to use for the new object is then specified by ui:part
It appears there is currently no way to specify default properties for the new object, e.g. its rdf:type. For rdf:type in particular, this means that forms for the new object will not be rendered by solid-panes, which discovers the relevant form based on its class.
Possible solutions
I don't whether there is a need for a more general templating mechanism, but at least for rdf:type, a solution could be to allow ui:Multiple
to also use ui:category
(as for ui:Classifier
) or ui:targetClass
(as for ui:Autocomplete
)
Another option would be to specify ui:from
(as for ui:Choice
) instead of ui:part
, and choose the ui:creationForm
based on the specified rdfs:Class.
Example use case
Generating a new observation
sosa:Observation ui:annotationForm :ObsForm.
:ObservationList ui:annotationForm :ObsListForm.
:ObsListForm
a ui:Multiple;
ui:part :ObsForm;
ui:property rdfs:member;
ui:category sosa:Observation.
:ThisObsList a :ObservationList.
Creating a new object in :ThisObsList would generate:
:ThisObsList rdfs:member :id1639432788935.
:id1639432788935 a sosa:Observation.
Edit: I've got an patch using ui:category here: https://github.com/josephguillaume/my-solidos-patches/blob/2860861f3ce4ddde9a8b0831ca520e4492878991/solid-ui.diff#L32
Edit: incidentally it's possible to get the desired behaviour by using ui:reverse with rdf:type as the ui:property
sosa:Observation ui:annotationForm :ObsForm.
:dummyClass ui:annotationForm :ObsListForm.
sosa:Observation a :dummyClass.
:ObsListForm
a ui:Multiple;
ui:part :ObsForm;
ui:reverse 1;
ui:property rdf:type.
Visiting sosa:Observation builds a form for :dummyClass which generates triples:
:newsubject a sosa:Observation
This might be more of a curiosity than a real solution.