OrcaSlicer icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
OrcaSlicer copied to clipboard

Ability to re-organize plate order

Open tlhintoq opened this issue 1 year ago • 23 comments

It would be of tremendous help to be able to re-order the plates of a job.

  • Sometimes its nice to move similar objects in sequence
  • Move completed plates to the end so you know what's next or where you left off printing
    • Or maybe just a clickable check box on the right-side tools to show [x] Done. I feel silly using the Lock tool right now for this indicator.
  • Re-organize once you slice and know the print time. For example: Two 4hrs jobs making up one 8hr shift of work, followed by a 12-16hr job to run overnight. Putting the jobs in workflow order would do a lot for job sequence planning.

image

tlhintoq avatar Jan 06 '24 02:01 tlhintoq

being able to reorganise plate order would be soooo nice.

Glenno-H avatar Jan 10 '24 22:01 Glenno-H

Keep alive - Still an issue in 2.0 developer/nightly

tlhintoq avatar Jan 17 '24 00:01 tlhintoq

Hey bot, please don't close me - this is still an issue.

tlhintoq avatar Feb 08 '24 07:02 tlhintoq

+1

mascenzi80 avatar Mar 02 '24 22:03 mascenzi80

Problem still exists in current 2.0 nightly as of 13mar2024

tlhintoq avatar Mar 13 '24 12:03 tlhintoq

+1, it would be great to see this feature added.

dstulken avatar Apr 03 '24 16:04 dstulken

Keep alive. Problem still exists in current 2.0 nightly as of 15apr2024

tlhintoq avatar Apr 15 '24 05:04 tlhintoq

I'm currently working on a project with over 20 build plates, and being able to re-order the build plates would help me keep the project more organized and print in the correct order. For doing just-in-time printing tasks for larger projects, this would help make sure the correct parts are printed when needed.

Moeser avatar May 03 '24 10:05 Moeser

Bot nudge.

tlhintoq avatar May 10 '24 06:05 tlhintoq

ohhhh yes please!!! I have a large project with 10+ plates and it would help sooo much if I could re-order them

stevenhu70 avatar May 10 '24 10:05 stevenhu70

This would be a very nice enhancement.

Shadowpheonix avatar May 19 '24 00:05 Shadowpheonix

This feature is definitely needed for larger projects.

geekypilot avatar May 20 '24 22:05 geekypilot

June '24 bot bump

+1 from me 🙏

emeyedeejay avatar Jun 03 '24 17:06 emeyedeejay

I would also like this. I have several large projects that have become messy over time, and plate reordering would help me work with them a bit more easily.

mgjv avatar Jul 04 '24 16:07 mgjv

This would be very helpful for keeping track of a large project

malteschulz avatar Jul 08 '24 13:07 malteschulz

@Azio-Pantheon I very much appreciate the work you did to give us the ability to move plate to the front. It should do a lot for workflow tracking and ordering.

  • Select - move to front
  • Select - move to front
  • {repeat}

Eventually you have the order you'd like to do the project in. Or just select - move to front, tells you the most recently printed part.

Thanks!

tlhintoq avatar Jul 30 '24 05:07 tlhintoq

Azio-Pantheon linked a pull request 3 weeks ago that will close this issue

3 weeks ago. Not yet merged. Just thought I'd throw a nudge in there for this. cc: @SoftFever

tlhintoq avatar Aug 16 '24 00:08 tlhintoq

+1 for this feature

MattiaConfalonieri avatar Sep 04 '24 14:09 MattiaConfalonieri

would also love to see this

mrambossek avatar Sep 05 '24 13:09 mrambossek

Me too! This would be awesome. My use case is 37 different ear ring models that each need a specific color/filament, I need to keep in alphabetical order to stay on top of all the stl's. Then I would like to insert production plates at the top/start/beginning to sort these into material based plates, to group them by filament/color. This would be a major enhancement for us commercial printers and super cool, even in a crude way so we can move the plates around (doesn't have to be drag and drop), some kind of index field in the plate properties to rearrange them would be fine.

image

MKloberg avatar Sep 16 '24 01:09 MKloberg

I just ran into another thing that makes no sense. There's a hard limit of how many plates can be created at 36 plates. Can we remove that limitation? Why not? Is there a reason for that? Sure, the users machine will blow at some point, but what if there is ample CPU/GPU available to lean that far out? To organize my jewelry project properly, I will need at least 10 more plates to make it work... Thank you for looking into this also.

image

MKloberg avatar Sep 16 '24 02:09 MKloberg

I need to keep in alphabetical order to stay on top of all the stl's.

What a fraking nightmare. Just a thought-Use the plate names? Or put the color on the plate? 2024-09-16_15-07-01

tlhintoq avatar Sep 16 '24 05:09 tlhintoq

I found where the plate limit is defined (hard-coded) if that helps. Would it be possible to make that a preference item - defaulting to 36, so we can crank it up if needed?

image

MKloberg avatar Sep 17 '24 01:09 MKloberg

I found where the plate limit is defined (hard-coded) if that helps. Would it be possible to make that a preference item - defaulting to 36, so we can crank it up if needed?

image

Looks simple enough. You should start a new thread, submit this as a feature request, since it is a separate issue.

Azio-Pantheon avatar Sep 17 '24 18:09 Azio-Pantheon

+1, please.

hermitdafunk avatar Apr 30 '25 22:04 hermitdafunk

I don't really feel like #6262 is a complete solution for this issue. Moving to front is nice, I guess, but it still doesn't let you reorder plates arbitrarily without manually shuffling them around.

If development effort is a concern, I think something like being able to right click on the plate in the object menu to bring up a pop up to set a plate index, like how cloning an object works, wouldn't be too time consuming.

dsluo avatar May 29 '25 13:05 dsluo

@Noisyfox Should folks like @dsluo and I keep making suggestions here even though this ticket is closed? Does that get any attention or would a new ticket be better?

I agree that more ability to re-organize would be nice. I kinda thought the move to first was a fast stop-gap measure until a more complete solution could be completed.

Here's a thought that shouldn't take any new UI, no new widget tools or mouse behaviours. Let us grab the plate itself from the object list and move the entire plate up and down between other plates, exactly the same way we grab an object on the plate and move it to change sequence. (also, a collapse all button at the top of the plate list would make this a ton easier)

Image

tlhintoq avatar May 30 '25 06:05 tlhintoq

@tlhintoq I think that makes sense. I've opened #9763 for that.

dsluo avatar May 30 '25 17:05 dsluo

+1

Lexxus17 avatar Jul 31 '25 22:07 Lexxus17

+1 to this feature.

I sometimes create new revisions of models, but need to retain the current revision. It would be really awesome if I could make a new plate with the updated print and then move it to the workflow space it belongs at.

scrith avatar Aug 14 '25 15:08 scrith