Simple-Gallery icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Simple-Gallery copied to clipboard

Add a Exif/Metadata editor.

Open ShapeShifter499 opened this issue 7 years ago • 22 comments

I like this Gallery app, works pretty good. I would like to know though if there could be an Exif/Metadata editor. It would be nice to have to be able edit out sensitive location and camera data before posting some photos online.

ShapeShifter499 avatar Jun 10 '17 05:06 ShapeShifter499

I would use this to add comments and to edit the location / gps info

Michele64 avatar Jul 05 '17 07:07 Michele64

I would like this

LivInTheLookingGlass avatar Aug 16 '17 05:08 LivInTheLookingGlass

+1 for that. So far really miss adding exif keywords and exif/iptc "star" rating for pictures in order to sort through larger collections.

kr428 avatar Nov 06 '18 11:11 kr428

i'm all for keeping Simple Gallery "simple".

for anyone looking to just remove EXIF data before sharing, try "Scrambled EXIF".

for anyone looking to do more extended EXIF editing, rating, and location mapping, try "A Photo Map".

both are found by searching the open source listings at https://search.f-droid.org/?q=exif

jmichael2497 avatar Jan 15 '19 22:01 jmichael2497

i'm all for keeping Simple Gallery "simple".

Agree with most of your suggestions - except for the "star" / favorite ratings. AFAICT SimpleGallery has the option to mark pictures as favorites so it only would make sense to allow for writing these information to the images files as well. :)

kr428 avatar Jan 16 '19 13:01 kr428

As @kr428 said, there should be a metadata tag that saves the "star"/favorite information to the image file, in order to enable the recovery of that information from a computer (after a backup from the smartphone).

Ivancaminal72 avatar Nov 05 '19 12:11 Ivancaminal72

@kr428 @Ivancaminal72 I've created a dedicated issue for storing the favourite/star rating in file https://github.com/SimpleMobileTools/Simple-Gallery/issues/1796 because I think it's only one part of what's requested here, but it might be much more simple to implement than an entire Exif/Metadata editor

jakommo avatar Apr 08 '20 20:04 jakommo

Would like to see this as well, would be nice to just have a clear all metadata button too.

seniorm0ment avatar Jul 07 '21 16:07 seniorm0ment

For people reaching our that issue, in the meantime (as a "workaround"), I started using exif-eraser. It removes exif metadata losslesly, it is FOSS, it doesn't require superfluous permissions and have a "share by default" option for people willing to just remove metadata before sending photos with some messanger.

szpak avatar Jul 07 '21 19:07 szpak

yeah there are many apps it's just nice to have it built right in

seniorm0ment avatar Jul 07 '21 20:07 seniorm0ment

there are many EXIF editor apps and there are many gallery apps, but there is no good app that does both

I use an app that can set EXIF descriptions for multiple selected photos

please consider adding this feature to the pro version of gallery

thanks

guaasamo avatar Sep 17 '21 20:09 guaasamo

there are many EXIF editor apps and there are many gallery apps, but there is no good app that does both

Have a look at Aves gallery: https://github.com/deckerst/aves

Donkey-Doug avatar Nov 27 '21 18:11 Donkey-Doug

starting with 6.23.0 it will be possible to remove EXIF values from the properties dialog

tibbi avatar Mar 20 '22 18:03 tibbi

starting with 6.23.0 it will be possible to remove EXIF values from the properties dialog

Great. Just please to remember to keep the orientation tag from Exif in the exported file ;).

szpak avatar Mar 20 '22 18:03 szpak

ye, orientation is the only one that wont be removed. There are likely many more tags that we could be removing, but that will improve over time.

tibbi avatar Mar 20 '22 19:03 tibbi

Actually there is a change, the EXIF remover wont be visible in the gallery on Android 11+ due to Googles strictened permissions, so this is joining the list of features that wont be available on those devices anymore. It will be there on lower OS versions or the file manager.

tibbi avatar Mar 20 '22 19:03 tibbi

if you find a gallery that can update EXIF in any way on Android 11+ and it was updated since november 2021, let me know.

tibbi avatar Mar 20 '22 20:03 tibbi

Actually there is a change, the EXIF remover wont be visible in the gallery on Android 11+ due to Googles strictened permissions

That's a pity :-/.

if you find a gallery that can update EXIF in any way on Android 11+ and it was updated since november 2021, let me know.

Does it have to be a gallery? exif-eraser seems to work on my Android 12 and it was updated in November 2021: https://github.com/Tommy-Geenexus/exif-eraser/releases/tag/v5.0.0

szpak avatar Mar 20 '22 20:03 szpak

right, they are recreating the whole file, we might add it like that too. I wanted to avoid it though, it could cause additional issues and the UX is pretty bad.

tibbi avatar Mar 20 '22 20:03 tibbi

Not always people would like to permanently remove the exif metadata from their photos. Personally, I do it before sending them via some app (e.g. social networks), so (under a hood) I make a copy of it (similarly to the photo edits). In fact, I would like to just remove exif and send that image to some other app and discard afterward. However, I remember that an author of exif-eraser told me, it is problematic (some temporary storage would need to be freed up periodically), so "exporting" them in a dedicated "no-exif" folder (with an option to automatically share with some other app) is ok for me (I can purge the folder occasionally).

szpak avatar Mar 21 '22 19:03 szpak

this change I wrote above is a permanent change, some function like "Remove EXIF and Share" is a whole different thing. It could be a pretty useful feature together with "Resize and Share"

tibbi avatar Mar 21 '22 19:03 tibbi

In fact, I would like to just remove exif and send that image to some other app and discard afterward. However, I remember that an author of exif-eraser told me, it is problematic (some temporary storage would need to be freed up periodically), so "exporting" them in a dedicated "no-exif" folder (with an option to automatically share with some other app) is ok for me (I can purge the folder occasionally).

you might be interested in https://f-droid.org/packages/de.kaffeemitkoffein.imagepipe which, yes makes a folder that does make its own folder, but easy enough to select all and delete with Gallery as needed.

meanwhile, i'm staying with 6.22.3 since i don't want to lose hidden folder view and other stuff that Google is making frustratingly difficult for end users and developers to do.

jmichael2497 avatar May 19 '22 23:05 jmichael2497