ScalablyTyped
Max parameters exceeded (and other strange things)
Reproduction: https://github.com/steinybot/bug-reports/tree/scalablytyped/max-parameters-exceeded
NOTE: This is using the changes in https://github.com/ScalablyTyped/Converter/pull/586
Trying to import and compile this:
ThisBuild / scalaVersion := "2.13.11"
enablePlugins(ScalaJSPlugin, ScalablyTypedConverterGenSourcePlugin)
organization := "com.example"
stOutputPackage := "web.typings"
stFlavour := Flavour.Slinky
stIgnore ++= List(
// Ignore this otherwise it fails with: anon is already defined as package anon
"@ant-design/cssinjs",
// For whatever reason when we ignore this we get three additional properties:
// linkDecoration, linkFocusDecoration, and linkHoverDecoration.
"csstype"
)
Compile / npmDependencies ++= Seq(
"antd" -> "5.12.1"
)
Compile / npmDevDependencies ++= Seq(
// Ignore this otherwise it fails with: anon is already defined as package anon
// For some reason...
"@types/react" -> "18.2.13"
)
stSourceGenMode := SourceGenMode.Manual(
(Compile / sourceDirectory).value / "scala"
)
Fails with:
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Bordered.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Ellipsis.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Expand.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Filter.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Fixed.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Radius.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Selection.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Size.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Sorter.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Sticky.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Summary.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] /Users/jason/src/bug-reports/src/main/scala/web.typings/antd/components/Virtual.scala:13:7: Platform restriction: a parameter list's length cannot exceed 254.
[error] def apply(
[error] ^
[error] 12 errors found
There are also some other weird things going on here which could be related to https://github.com/ScalablyTyped/Converter/pull/586, I'm not too sure.
If we do not ignore "@ant-design/cssinjs" then there is a duplicate anon package.
What is really strange is that excluding the dev dependency on "@types/react" -> "18.2.13" also leads to this duplicate anon package. Why would having fewer dependencies have more packages?
Also if we do not ignore "csstype" then we get three fewer properties and we do not exceed the parameter limit. This is also very odd. Why does ignoring it lead to more properties?
Sometimes to pickup the changes we have to bust the cache manually:
rm -rf ./target/streams/_global/stImportSources/_global/streams/input.json && sbt 'stImportSources;compile'
Hey there
So yeah, a bunch of things here.
too many parameters
The error you're seeing is that the react component identification code mistakenly identifies some code as react components, for instance the default member here. I don't really think I can fix it, since the name and signature is sufficiently similar to a react component that if I do fix it we'll lose other components in other libraries. Would be interesting to see if the typescript compiler accepts it as a react component actually.
The type which is taken to be the type of props has more than 254 required members, so that's where Scala.js starts to complain when they are all put into the apply method which initializes the react component builder.
I think I'll hack around it and say if a component has more than X required members, where X is above say 50, we drop it. nobody is gonna supply more than 50 required props anyway.
anon
anon is a package or object we create so there is a place to put types which didn't have a name in typescript. These could theoretically be output as structural types now, but it's not so convenient to use. So the existence of the package or object depends on whether there were any such types in the typescript code.
Whether it's a package or an object depends on the number of classes inside it. It may sound ridiculous for this to flip-flop like this, but it's a compromise between git (which likes fewer files) and intellij (which does not like scala files with thousands of lines of code)
There are some details surrounding this, where a given anonymous type may be imported from a dependency, and the scala anon class ends up in that library instead and the downstream library will refer to it by that name. I suppose this can explain what you're seeing with anon package appearing and disappearing
if you're seeing anon is already defined as package anon again, could you see if there is both an object and a package in the generated code? I think it's more likely not invalidated by zinc, so an sbt clean should fix it. Otherwise this is a bug.
A final thing here is a suggestion to only use stIgnore when needed (failing import/compile). it's possible that names are resolved to the wrong thing, if there are similarly named things in the global namespace of another library.
ST not picking up changes.
Might it be that ST is not picking up changes in Compile / npmDevDependencies? because that is only taken into consideration if you set stIncludeDev := true. It's not on by default as it may affect the generated result negatively. The reason is that npm depenencies may have circular dependencies, while ST needs to be strict and create a tree of libraries. As such, considering dev dependencies "earlier" may cause a suboptimal tree shape to be chose, and a bunch of types set to Any when dependency links are broken.
if you see any other changes not being picked up by ST I'd love some details, as that would be a very irritating bug. you should not have to delete those files ever.
FWIW I simplified the build a bit:
organization := "com.example"
stOutputPackage := "web.typings"
stFlavour := Flavour.Slinky
Compile / npmDependencies ++= Seq(
"antd" -> "5.12.1",
"@types/react" -> "18.2.13"
)
stSourceGenMode := SourceGenMode.Manual((Compile / sourceDirectory).value / "scala")
ran stImportSources with a snapshot of ST master, compiled, and it worked. if you're building antd wrappers you should add this as well
stMinimize := Selection.AllExcept("antd")
as well to dramatically reduce the amount of code