Ryujinx-Games-List icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
Ryujinx-Games-List copied to clipboard

Fire Emblem: Engage - 0100A6301214E000

Open Bjorn29512 opened this issue 2 years ago • 44 comments

Game Name

Fire Emblem: Engage

Game Update Version

1.0.0

Emulator Build Version

1.1.588

Graphics Backend

Vulkan

Hardware Specs

  • CPU: i5-12400f

  • GPU: NVIDIA GTX 1660 Super

  • RAM: 32GB

Game State

  • Works as intended on Vulkan and no discernible issues so far.
  • GPUs with less than 8GB Vram need texture recompression enabled to avoid out of memory crashes in the main hub.

Screenshots

image image image image image image

Log File

No response

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 19 '23 21:01 Bjorn29512

The game is awfully aliased, even with resolution scaler (It even looks more aliased at 3x or 4x than at 2x, weirdly. At least on my 1080p monitor)

I guess fixing this would need a game mod. Post Processing PR doesn't really help here, at least not significantly, and does add some blurriness even with SMAA Ultra

Foul-Tarnished avatar Jan 19 '23 22:01 Foul-Tarnished

The game is awfully aliased, even with resolution scaler (It even looks more aliased at 3x or 4x than at 2x, weirdly. At least on my 1080p monitor)

I guess fixing this would need a game mod. Post Processing PR doesn't really help here, at least not significantly, and does add some blurriness even with SMAA Ultra

I am on a 1080p monitor as well but dont share this issue, are you playing in windowed mode with scaling ?

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 19 '23 23:01 Bjorn29512

Fullscreen

x2 image

x3 image

it looks awful, but I guess it's just the game

Foul-Tarnished avatar Jan 20 '23 00:01 Foul-Tarnished

For me the image is much cleaner and sharper when using scaling and it seems to be working as intended, it does seem like maybe the game uses its own AA which doesn't scale well or perhaps some elements on characters aren't being properly scaled but idk.

Native :

Ryujinx Nvidia Profile Screenshot 2023 01 20 - 06 08 03 86 Ryujinx Nvidia Profile Screenshot 2023 01 20 - 06 11 12 83

2x : Ryujinx Nvidia Profile Screenshot 2023 01 20 - 06 08 16 95 Ryujinx Nvidia Profile Screenshot 2023 01 20 - 06 11 24 30

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 20 '23 00:01 Bjorn29512

For me the image is much cleaner and sharper when using scaling and it seems to be working as intended, it does seem like maybe the game uses its own AA which doesn't scale well or perhaps some elements on characters aren't being properly scaled but idk.

Native :

Ryujinx Nvidia Profile Screenshot 2023 01 20 - 06 08 03 86 Ryujinx Nvidia Profile Screenshot 2023 01 20 - 06 11 12 83

2x : Ryujinx Nvidia Profile Screenshot 2023 01 20 - 06 08 16 95 Ryujinx Nvidia Profile Screenshot 2023 01 20 - 06 11 24 30

Still looks aliased.

GamerzHell9137 avatar Jan 20 '23 04:01 GamerzHell9137

I tested this briefly on my Mac and it seems to work pretty well. A few things I did notice:

  1. Some split second flickering/ rendering issue was seen. But it was so brief that I could not capture an image of it.
  2. The upscaling seems to not work during closeups of characters talking. Could not tell a difference between 1X, 2X, 3X at all. During battle it feels like it works but not really? Marginal difference between 1X and 2X.
  3. The upscaling seems to only clearly work during the free roaming section.

PekaPete avatar Jan 20 '23 07:01 PekaPete

When using OpenGL in Mesa, there will be a texture error, and the character will randomly appear black head or body

yuwenhua653 avatar Jan 20 '23 08:01 yuwenhua653

It crashes when walking around Soranel (the floating island). Is it just me or does it happen to you too?

Sha-tan avatar Jan 20 '23 10:01 Sha-tan

updated

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 20 '23 12:01 Bjorn29512

Here is a cool thing, when using scaling, if you just loaded into the game, and into an exploring section, where you can walk around and talk to npc's etc, it'll be at the scaling resolution you set and look really nice, however, if you then go to the save menu and back out, the fxaa and dynamic scaler seem to kick back in into overdrive and completely ruin the image again, like it's no longer running at whatever you set it at.

Digitaln3ko avatar Jan 20 '23 14:01 Digitaln3ko

It crashes when walking around Soranel (the floating island). Is it just me or does it happen to you too?

Same here, so far I got 3 random crashes, 2 walking around and one at the start of a battle in chapter 2

ChristopherCalderon avatar Jan 20 '23 23:01 ChristopherCalderon

It crashes when walking around Soranel (the floating island). Is it just me or does it happen to you too?

Same here, so far I got 3 random crashes, 2 walking around and one at the start of a battle in chapter 2

do you guys have AMD gpu a few ppl on discord reported crashes with amd gpu, i would recommend joining the discord and posting logs in support, if so i will make an update in the report for AMD

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 21 '23 00:01 Bjorn29512

It crashes when walking around Soranel (the floating island). Is it just me or does it happen to you too?

Same here, so far I got 3 random crashes, 2 walking around and one at the start of a battle in chapter 2

do you guys have AMD gpu a few ppl on discord reported crashes with amd gpu, i would recommend joining the discord and posting logs in support, if so i will make an update in the report for AMD

Im on nvidia gpu

ChristopherCalderon avatar Jan 21 '23 01:01 ChristopherCalderon

It crashes when walking around Soranel (the floating island). Is it just me or does it happen to you too?

Same here, so far I got 3 random crashes, 2 walking around and one at the start of a battle in chapter 2

do you guys have AMD gpu a few ppl on discord reported crashes with amd gpu, i would recommend joining the discord and posting logs in support, if so i will make an update in the report for AMD

Im on nvidia gpu

then post a log here or the discord when you crash.

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 21 '23 01:01 Bjorn29512

then post a log here or the discord when you crash.

Sorry for taking a while, now that I was looking for a crash it didnt crash lol But I got one again, walking around the somniel, I was able to play just fine the chapter before it crashed tho, so probly the problem is in the somniel Ryujinx_1.1.578_2023-01-20_22-51-49.log

edit: I forgot to mention, this time I was using the wave 1 dlc, but I kinda doubt it has something to do with the crash because it was basically the same conditions as the past crashes I had (walking in the somniel)

ChristopherCalderon avatar Jan 21 '23 05:01 ChristopherCalderon

then post a log here or the discord when you crash.

Sorry for taking a while, now that I was looking for a crash it didnt crash lol But I got one again, walking around the somniel, I was able to play just fine the chapter before it crashed tho, so probly the problem is in the somniel Ryujinx_1.1.578_2023-01-20_22-51-49.log

Need texture recompression enabled on GPU with less than 6GB vram to avoid crash there and for the love of god update your drivers

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 21 '23 05:01 Bjorn29512

Updated

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 21 '23 05:01 Bjorn29512

It crashes when walking around Soranel (the floating island). Is it just me or does it happen to you too?

Same here, so far I got 3 random crashes, 2 walking around and one at the start of a battle in chapter 2

do you guys have AMD gpu a few ppl on discord reported crashes with amd gpu, i would recommend joining the discord and posting logs in support, if so i will make an update in the report for AMD

Looking at the discord it seems that the AMD crashes occur when entering and leaving loading areas and cutscenes with resolution scaled above native. I can conferm this is very consistent for me.

All the logs end with a pattern of :

00:01:12.791 |S| HLE.OsThread.20 ServicePctl IsFreeCommunicationAvailable: Stubbed. 
00:01:21.162 |W| HLE.OsThread.10 ServiceNv Wait: GPU processing thread is too slow, waiting on CPU...
00:01:22.162 |E| HLE.OsThread.10 Gpu WaitOnSyncpoint: Wait on syncpoint 1 for threshold 5326 took more than 1000ms, resuming execution...
00:01:33.881 |I| .NET ThreadPool Worker Ptc Save: Saved Profiling Info (size: 230447 bytes, profiled functions: 66456).
00:01:41.560 |W| HLE.OsThread.10 ServiceNv Wait: GPU processing thread is too slow, waiting on CPU...
00:01:42.561 |E| HLE.OsThread.10 Gpu WaitOnSyncpoint: Wait on syncpoint 1 for threshold 7587 took more than 1000ms, resuming execution... 

Before ending, if this means anything to anyone.

andyblarblar avatar Jan 21 '23 06:01 andyblarblar

Updated again with AMD bug

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 21 '23 13:01 Bjorn29512

Updated again with AMD bug

Tested the AMD issue on linux with mesa and the game runs fine (outside of the normal AA issues), so it does seem like the windows drivers are the cause of the crashes (suprise there).

andyblarblar avatar Jan 21 '23 20:01 andyblarblar

Issue running on Steam Deck with latest Ryujinx version in Vulkan. When running around the open areas, objects seem to pop in and out, even relatively close ones. This doesn't happen with OpenGL. Can’t replicate this on Windows.

massiveinvisible avatar Jan 21 '23 21:01 massiveinvisible

Issue running on Steam Deck with latest Ryujinx version in Vulkan. When running around the open areas, objects seem to pop in and out, even relatively close ones. This doesn't happen with OpenGL. Can’t replicate this on Windows.

I can replicate this issue with an AMD GPU on desktop ubuntu as well.

andyblarblar avatar Jan 21 '23 23:01 andyblarblar

Updated (Issue Fixed)

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 22 '23 13:01 Bjorn29512

Screen tearing present during motion. Running Vulcan with VSync on. Usually just on the top quarter of the screen, nothing unplayable. i9/3090TI

EDIT: You can play with VSync off, but with unlocked FPS the menus and movement start to accelerate, causing some visual hiccups and slowdowns during scene transitions.

michael-stubbs avatar Jan 24 '23 18:01 michael-stubbs

I have a lot of crashes with Vulkan on Ryujinx 1.1.595, game version 1.1.0. I switched to OpenGL and now it's not crashing but I have a little more stuttering + the cutscenes freeze (only video audio is fine). I got some serious visual bugs on Vulkan like when you have old drivers (magenta textures, artifacting) but not on OpenGL mode. My Specs: Operating System: Windows 10 Pro 64-bit (10.0, Build 19044) Processor: Intel(R) Pentium(R) CPU G4560 @ 3.50GHz (4 CPUs), ~3.5GHz Available OS Memory: 8142MB RAM DirectX Version: DirectX 12 Card name: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 950 Display Memory: 6078 MB Dedicated Memory: 2007 MB Shared Memory: 4070 MB Current Mode: 1152 x 864 (32 bit) (75Hz)

Zheyres avatar Jan 25 '23 18:01 Zheyres

switch back to vulkan and enable texture re compression to avoid crashes, its likely crashing cause you run out of memory as the game needs 6gb + vram since the game uses ASTC

Bjorn29512 avatar Jan 25 '23 18:01 Bjorn29512

Having an issue with Ryujinx and cutscenes in this game. The opening song and any cutscenes in game start freezing while the sound plays. Tried both OpenGL and Vulkan, tried with Vsync on/off. Any ideas? Ryujinx performs flawlessly other than the cutscene freeze.

Yuzu runs the game well and the cutscenes just fine, the issue with yuzu is the stuttering after some playtime.

Windows 10 Home 64-bit (10.0 Build 19045) AMD FX 8320 8 Core 3.5GHz Nvidia Geforce GTX 1650 3949 VRAM, 8139 MB Shared, 12088 MB Total 1920 x 1080 32 bit 60hz Direct X 12 16GB RAM

ashy20102 avatar Feb 02 '23 20:02 ashy20102

Just some vertex explosions. https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/20160968/216585295-41a34367-d73e-4395-823b-87dc690a1e7a.mp4

ayurai avatar Feb 03 '23 10:02 ayurai

switch back to vulkan and enable texture re compression to avoid crashes, its likely crashing cause you run out of memory as the game needs 6gb + vram since the game uses ASTC

still crashes here and there :(

Windows 10 Home 64-bit (10.0 Build 19045.2486) AMD Ryzen 5 3600 6-Core Processor 3.95 GHz AMD RX 550/50 4000 VRAM, Direct X 12 16GB RAM

image

image

kuroganashi avatar Feb 03 '23 14:02 kuroganashi

switch back to vulkan and enable texture re compression to avoid crashes, its likely crashing cause you run out of memory as the game needs 6gb + vram since the game uses ASTC

still crashes here and there :(

Windows 10 Home 64-bit (10.0 Build 19045.2486) AMD Ryzen 5 3600 6-Core Processor 3.95 GHz AMD RX 550/50 4000 VRAM, Direct X 12 16GB RAM

image

image

hmm it shouldn't if you have texture re compression and not using scaling for amd, might wanna post a log for this one either here or the discord server.

Bjorn29512 avatar Feb 03 '23 15:02 Bjorn29512