AltSnap icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
AltSnap copied to clipboard

Balance Preserving Audio Control

Open Ichisich opened this issue 2 years ago • 1 comments

Windows has the quirk to reset the balance settings when lowering the volume to 0.

To illustrate, lowering the volume to 2 keeps the balance: https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/31080003/165258195-50adf903-9af6-4e36-9294-75e547ade386.mp4

Lowering to 0 resets the balance: https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/31080003/165258250-3eef6be6-815c-426b-bdde-ffda2343e1bd.mp4

Muting also keeps the balance: https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/31080003/165258320-7443a589-4aa0-4ed2-85b7-e8bef34e9a2e.mp4

To counter this quirk, I adapted my autohotkey-script to mute instead of lowering the volume from 2 to 0.

AppsKey & PgDn:: SoundGet, Volume if (Volume >= 4) { Send {Volume_Down} return } else { Send {Volume_Mute} return }

Would be nice if Altsnap could handle volume control similar.

Ichisich avatar Apr 26 '22 08:04 Ichisich

Interesting, I never realized this bug was here. It seems it was already there even on Windows XP/7 and I guess Microsoft is not going to fix it, so better avoid it as you suggest. I guess Microsoft considers this like a feature.

RamonUnch avatar Apr 26 '22 09:04 RamonUnch

AltSnap1.62test20_x64.zip

Should fix it. When you decrease volume it will mute instead of setting to Zero.

RamonUnch avatar Nov 20 '23 19:11 RamonUnch