RTX icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
RTX copied to clipboard

Let's not go the way of Meta's Galactica

Open dkoslicki opened this issue 3 years ago • 3 comments

If you've seen the new, this language model was shut down rather quickly due to its ridiculous answers. Trying out one similar test query (with vaccines and autism), on our system, I got: https://arax.ncats.io/?r=99378 .

This came from RTX-KG2 (don't know if you want to cross-post this issue @saramsey @amykglen @acevedol).

The underlying SemMedDB snippets look reasonable, but the predicates sure are unfortunate.

dkoslicki avatar Nov 22 '22 04:11 dkoslicki

@dkoslicki thank you for bringing this up. Yeah, that's awkward:

Screen Shot 2022-11-21 at 9 44 15 PM

But perhaps a useful use-case to figure out how to improve ARAX?

saramsey avatar Nov 22 '22 05:11 saramsey

Precisely: an example to sanity check our ranking and filtering

dkoslicki avatar Nov 22 '22 05:11 dkoslicki

I wonder if this is a case where we need some special logic in the KG2 build process to correct some known problems. And this is also a case where we want to use the "NOT" modifier to statements. So that that statement is "vaccines NOT biolink:causes autism spectrum disorder".

edeutsch avatar Nov 22 '22 06:11 edeutsch

Just checked and while this particular query now returns zero results, a modification (different CURIEs) does: https://arax.test.transltr.io/?r=247697. Technical debt, or....?

dkoslicki avatar Jun 19 '24 16:06 dkoslicki

closing in favor of #2303

dkoslicki avatar Jul 03 '24 17:07 dkoslicki