linux-cli icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
linux-cli copied to clipboard

Is this repo still being maintained?

Open ElmoTheWizard opened this issue 2 years ago • 100 comments

The last commit was 3 months ago, while the windows app was updated 13 days ago.

ElmoTheWizard avatar Mar 03 '22 00:03 ElmoTheWizard

Hey @ElmoTheWizard

Yes, all repos are being maintained, although it should be noted that we are currently working a new and improved multi-platform client which will support Wireguard and should not be fully dependent on NetworkManager nor keyring backends (as currently we're tied to Gnome-keyring and KWallet). Thus it should allow even more distros to use our official client without having hard dependencies baked in.

Either way, we'll be releasing a couple new features for the current client in the coming weeks, stay tuned :)

PS: Please don't close this issue, as other might find this useful.

calexandru2018 avatar Mar 03 '22 16:03 calexandru2018

@calexandru2018 let distributions get an early preview if possible, so we can adapt our packages :smile:

alexandrevicenzi avatar Apr 07 '22 14:04 alexandrevicenzi

@calexandru2018 Any updates on this upcoming multi-platform release? Any way we can test it yet?

bionicworx avatar May 18 '22 10:05 bionicworx

we are currently working a new and improved multi-platform client

This sounds good. Can we track this new version somewhere? Is it open source?

Redsandro avatar Jul 06 '22 23:07 Redsandro

Either way, we'll be releasing a couple new features for the current client in the coming weeks, stay tuned :)

Four months later and these updates are nowhere to be seen. Are we ever getting Wireguard support? It's over a year since Wireguard support was added for other platforms, whereas Linux users are left waiting with no ETAs or updates in sight.

Bruflot avatar Jul 16 '22 22:07 Bruflot

Will the new client still depend on systemd?

benstockil avatar Aug 04 '22 10:08 benstockil

hopefully this new client brings an flatpak or appimage, many people hate installing stuff from terminal

FillingTheVoidOnYT avatar Aug 05 '22 07:08 FillingTheVoidOnYT

hopefully this new client brings an flatpak or appimage, many people hate installing stuff from terminal

Flatpaks are terrible for applications with system level integration. I don't think any sort of permission setup will allow it to work.

alastortenebris avatar Aug 09 '22 18:08 alastortenebris

make the new repo public. I've been waiting for months and I honestly don't care if it's broken. I just need to see something

GloriousWizard avatar Aug 10 '22 04:08 GloriousWizard

It's a shame the linux client is basically useless...there is no offficial/easy way to run at boot and I tried lots of stuff.

And with this thread i know this client won't have any future...so probably better for me to cancel my protonvpn and switch to another provider that is more linux friendly !

Nottt avatar Aug 17 '22 19:08 Nottt

@Nottt I'm using the Wireguard configurations until the new client is released publicly. It works well enough for now, but the lack of news from the dev team concerns me about how long I'm going to be stuck with this workaround.

benstockil avatar Aug 18 '22 20:08 benstockil

Hi, when the new version is available, can you please post info it here?

I watched this topic :-)

LunaDoll avatar Aug 29 '22 05:08 LunaDoll

It's a shame the linux client is basically useless...there is no offficial/easy way to run at boot and I tried lots of stuff.

And with this thread i know this client won't have any future...so probably better for me to cancel my protonvpn and switch to another provider that is more linux friendly !

mullvad has a great linux client

FillingTheVoidOnYT avatar Sep 29 '22 21:09 FillingTheVoidOnYT

iVPN has a good linux client as well, and has working UPnP from my experience (for some reason Mullvad did not port forward correctly, even after setting a port online.)

Can't believe it's taking so long for a non-jank linux client, and they are not giving status updates either; Proton looking a little corporate from where I sit, and not in a good way.

Slayer5934 avatar Oct 05 '22 17:10 Slayer5934

Seven month's later, still no wireguard support.

Zylquinal avatar Oct 06 '22 05:10 Zylquinal

Hey, @calexandru2018

~A half year has passed~ Eight months have passed since https://github.com/ProtonVPN/linux-cli/issues/64#issuecomment-1058224569, still no wireguard support, no visible significant development.

It is a real pain to wait without knowing roughly when they are planned to be done. I know you are probably very busy, but can you give us regular updates on the internal progress and development plans?

jbas23 avatar Nov 03 '22 05:11 jbas23

Hey @jbas23

I'll copy/paste what I've wrote on another ticket:

Apologize for not being much active here, but we're currently working really hard on the new client, so that we don't have the same dependency issues that we currently have.

The idea for the new client is to be as modular as possible, meaning that if someone would like to run native backends instead of 3rd party (ie native openvpn/wg vs NM openvpn/wg ) that would happen transparently. The only difference would be which packages are required (we'll be creating meta-packages that help with installation). Apart from that we're working also on making the applications in general to be much more reliable, and all of this takes time. Initially the rebuild app won't have many features, but we intend in releasing it gradually.

At this current point we have some of the sub-packages written, and we're working mostly in refining (quality and reliability) some of them and at the same time re-writing the apps.

calexandru2018 avatar Nov 04 '22 09:11 calexandru2018

Why not make the project public? Even if it's far from stable, it will make people stop asking about the progress of the new client.

GloriousWizard avatar Nov 06 '22 16:11 GloriousWizard