plant-trait-ontology icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
plant-trait-ontology copied to clipboard

New term request:Canopy width

Open KarthikaRajendran opened this issue 9 years ago • 6 comments

Definition:Width of the canopy Method:Average canopy width of three/five representative plants of an accession. Scale:cm

KarthikaRajendran avatar Nov 13 '15 19:11 KarthikaRajendran

The expression 'three/five' will not make sense to most people. Be as explicit as possible.

On Fri, Nov 13, 2015 at 2:50 PM, Karthika Rajendran < [email protected]> wrote:

Definition:Width of the canopy Method:Average canopy width of three/five representative plants of an accession. Scale:cm

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/Planteome/plant-trait-ontology/issues/348.

phismith avatar Nov 14 '15 16:11 phismith

Definition: Width of the canopy Method: Average canopy width of randomly selected plants in each individual plots. Scale:cm

KarthikaRajendran avatar Nov 17 '15 14:11 KarthikaRajendran

the term request is for the trait "canopy width" only, not for its measurement method and its scale. So "Average canopy width of three/five representative plants of an accession." is not meant to be added in TO. It is addressed to the lentil breeding community and I doubt it does not make sense to them.

Remark: "canopy width" could actually match with TO:0006062 "plant width" though the TO definition is not the definition of a trait but of a variable: "The average width of a plant measured across an axis such as the main stem/stalk."

leova avatar Nov 17 '15 14:11 leova

'canopy width' sounds like a trait of a population of trees, e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canopy_%28biology%29

On 17 Nov 2015, at 6:54, Léo V. wrote:

the term request is for the trait "canopy width" only, not for its measurement method and its scale. So "Average canopy width of three/five representative plants of an accession." is not meant to be added in TO. It is addressed to the lentil breeding community and I doubt it does not make sense to them.

Remark: "canopy width" could actually match with TO:0006062 "plant width" though the TO definition is not the definition of a trait but of a variable: "The average width of a plant measured across an axis such as the main stem/stalk."


Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub: https://github.com/Planteome/plant-trait-ontology/issues/348#issuecomment-157392063

cmungall avatar Nov 17 '15 17:11 cmungall

Soybean has a trait “canopy width” which is the width of the canopy of a soybean plant. Canopy width can also apply to a single tree as in “the tree’s canopy was”. Foresters also use “crown size” or “crown width” to refer to the area occupied by the leaves and branches of a tree. This is an important parameter in urban landscaping design. There is also a term “crown extent” which appears to be the circumference of the crown of a tree. Crown height, is the hight of a tree at its tallest point, which might be equivalent to “plant height”.

See: http://www.fs.fed.us/psw/programs/uesd/uep/products/cufr_94_PP01_39.PDF https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leaf_area_index

maxglycine avatar Nov 17 '15 20:11 maxglycine

We may also say the soybean term "canopy width" is similar to lentil term "canopy width"

KarthikaRajendran avatar Nov 30 '15 14:11 KarthikaRajendran