elastic4s
elastic4s copied to clipboard
Philippus
ODFE support and path forward with fork
Due to licensing changes in ES, the OpenDistroForElastic will fork last viable ES (7.10) , and since 7.11 is already out they will probably start diverging soon.
I don't suppose you plan to maintain patches for 7.10 in meantime and in any fashion support both DBs? If not I may just have to fork this and maintain it for ODFE. What do you think?
I will probably support both (if both are popular) but I want to see what happens with ODFE first. Will it succeed or fizzle out. I remember when Hudson/Jenkins was forked and Hudson kind of died out. Mabye ODFE will take over and original ES will die out.
In other words, I'm delaying any decisions until I see what happens over the next month or three. I've also got to do this at the same time as adding dotty support.
But rest assured, I won't ignore ODFE if it takes off.
I'd be happy for anyone to join as a contributor here, regardless of how we proceed.
Sounds good. So the plan is to have a separate branch for 7.10 release so we can patch it as well in meantime? I'm happy to help out with any further changes
Yes we could do. I guess the only difference right now is the client dependency ? We could even move the elastic dependency to another module and make it opt in - it's only a HTTP client after all.
I haven't tracked the changelog yet. But I guess in future there'll be more breaking changes so it's something we need to think of.
I've been reading about it here: https://discuss.opendistrocommunity.dev/c/forking-elasticsearch-kibana/50 So once they have something released we can branch 7.10 for that.