SparseR-CNN icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
SparseR-CNN copied to clipboard

train w/o pre-trained backbone

Open StarsMyDestination opened this issue 4 years ago • 3 comments

Hi, thank you for this excellent work first! Have you tried to train the model from scratch? I observed some strange things:

  1. the mAP is much lower than reported (in fact mAP<30);
  2. the init proposals not learned well, and I visualized it to find that the init boxes barely changed even the training process was finished.

Any ideas? thx a lot ^_^

StarsMyDestination avatar Apr 22 '21 07:04 StarsMyDestination

Actually, I printed the 'init_proposal_boxes.weight' of your provided model r50_100pro_3x_model.pth, and the boxes are not distributed as the paper says: image above image is snipped from paper.

image the actual proposal boxes in the provided pth file, and it almost the same, obviously not randomly distributed on the image to cover the whole image area.

Is there any details not illustrated in the paper or I misunderstood something? If not, how to explain this?

StarsMyDestination avatar Apr 22 '21 09:04 StarsMyDestination

Hi~ For training the model from scratch, we didn't try it. I guess it may need more training epochs. For the init boxes, please see this issue: link.

PeizeSun avatar Apr 22 '21 10:04 PeizeSun

@PeizeSun thx for your reply. I will first try the random init, if I find something I will leave a comment here,

StarsMyDestination avatar Apr 23 '21 09:04 StarsMyDestination