topola-webtrees icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
topola-webtrees copied to clipboard

Privacy is out.

Open mrqd9 opened this issue 4 years ago • 3 comments

Topola ignores all privacy settings

mrqd9 avatar Oct 26 '21 12:10 mrqd9

I had installed the topola-webtrees-addon as admin and then opened it directly in wt. After that I logged out of wt and opened the addon again as a visitor. When calling the addon as a visitor, I could see all pedigree-data, even those that should be locked due to the webtrees privacy settings. This also worked from another computer, so I could rule out local (browser)caching.

How could this be? Was all the data that the admin had access to transferred to a topola/cors-server on the first call and cached there - without privacy settings?

Please clarify!

Regardless of the above, I think that topola-addon needs to indicate during installation/configuration that data is being transferred to another server and there should also be an option to restrict the scope of data (e.g. no data with privacy settings).

ungeahnt avatar Apr 29 '22 14:04 ungeahnt

I added a note about respecting privacy settings to the readme.

I would gladly accept a pull request that would add this capability to the addon. PHP falls outside of my sphere of competence :wink:

The addon does not send any data to another server. The Topola Viewer application is indeed loaded from https://pewu.github.io/topola-viewer but all data from Webtrees is contained inside the user's browser. This is a common concern and the application is specifically designed not to send data to servers out of control of the user. See also a description for the Gramps addon: https://gramps-project.org/wiki/index.php/Addon:Interactive_Family_Tree

PeWu avatar May 17 '22 17:05 PeWu

This is very important because even Google search has access via Topola to all private data.

hartenthaler avatar May 18 '22 09:05 hartenthaler