PathOfBuilding icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
PathOfBuilding copied to clipboard

Banner Scaling Bugged? (Dread Banner)

Open mas0ny1 opened this issue 3 weeks ago • 9 comments

Check version

  • [x] I'm running the latest version of Path of Building and I've verified this by checking the changelog

Check for duplicates

  • [x] I've checked for duplicate open and closed issues by using the search function of the issue tracker

What platform are you running Path of Building on?

Windows

How is Path of Building expected to behave?

When I use Dread banner on my character in game, my block values are not accurate to what POB shows they should be:

Image Image

I'm not sure if I've missed a conditional but I just imported this character fresh into pob to make sure and did not touch any config settings

How does Path of Building behave?

POB values seem to be slightly higher than what they should be, they should match in game

How to reproduce the issue

Click Dread banner -> Compare with Imported POB

PoB for PoE1 build code

https://pobb.in/tUehoFHc6jhK

Screenshots

Image Image

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 02:11 mas0ny1

On first investigation, this seems like a bug in PoE. Are you able to unspec some max valour or aura effect nodes to provide some more data points to work off of? All the math checks out from PoB, so I'm not sure what is going on here.

Wires77 avatar Nov 30 '25 04:11 Wires77

Image Image

Unspecced mastery (10% less aura effect)

Think your right about it being a bug in poe considering unspeccing this node changed nothing

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 05:11 mas0ny1

95 Valour, same aura effect as original pob

Image Image

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 05:11 mas0ny1

Image Image

85 valour, same aura effect as original

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 05:11 mas0ny1

85 valour, reservation mastery and champion of the cause unspecced

Image Image

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 05:11 mas0ny1

85 valour, aura mastery unspeced, champion of the cause specced

Image Image

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 05:11 mas0ny1

Honestly not sure whether the in game menu is trustable, considering I did also check the maths in pob and it looked right Perhaps its just a bug in game I'm not 100% sure Or maybe the aura effect mastery doesnt apply to banners

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 05:11 mas0ny1

My Characters Rez without Banners Image

My Characters Rez with defiance banner with 105 valour (aura mastery unspecced) Image

My Characters rez with the aura mastery specced (original pob). 105 valour

Image

For Context this is the relevant elemental resistance node for banners

Image

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 05:11 mas0ny1

Okay I figured out the issue Champion of the Cause does not work on banners, my fire rez was 216% with it specced, and unspecced

However the aura effect node on that wheel before, did change my resistances when I unspecced it

And the aura mastery for 10% doesnt seem to work for banners

The wording is exactly the same on champion of the cause and the aura effect node so I think it must be a bug with poe, or a tooltip bug that's universal to all banner calculations? I think it's just not applying when it should

lettme know what you think, could POB have it changed so that the aura mastery and champion of the cause doesnt apply to banners reflecting the bug in game perhaps?

mas0ny1 avatar Nov 30 '25 05:11 mas0ny1