taucmdr icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
taucmdr copied to clipboard

Interact with existing project from outside project-tree (feature request)

Open eugeneswalker opened this issue 3 years ago • 3 comments

It would be nice if there were a way to run experiments outside of the project-tree. Perhaps more generally to be able to interact with an existing taucmdr project from outside the project directory via a CLI opt.

Maybe like tau --tau-dir=<PROJECT_DIR> dash would invoke the dashboard routine in the context of <PROJECT_DIR>

For instance, if my tau init'd project directory is $PROJECT_DIR and I want to run a trial from outside-the-project directory, it looks like an attempt was made at one point to make this possible:

$> tau trial create --help
...
Optional Arguments:
...
  --tau-dir [tau_dir]         Project directory location.
                                - default: None
...

However, --tau-dir doesn't seem to work:

$> tau trial create --tau-dir=$PROJECT_DIR mpirun -np 48 $PROJECT_DIR/bin/binary
[TAU] CRITICAL
[TAU]
[TAU] Project directory not found in '/pylon5/ac31lhp/lpeyrala/Sept2020_incompressibleTest/test6' or any of its parent directories.
[TAU]
[TAU] Hint: Make sure that you have already run the `tau initialize` command in this directory or any of its parent directories.
[TAU]
[TAU] Please contact <[email protected]> for assistance.

@zbeekman

eugeneswalker avatar Jan 13 '21 16:01 eugeneswalker

We may want to implement selecting a project directory as a global flag by extending the existing storage-level flag, which is done by passing an argument -@level to a command, e.g., tau project list -@user. The code that implements that flag is located at:

https://github.com/ParaToolsInc/taucmdr/blob/e14f62de27b1712c5c0a45f9af8aecff17519e2d/packages/taucmdr/cli/arguments.py#L632-L653

We could possibly extend it to allow a path in addition to a storage level name. We may want to also add support for it to some other commands; it is not supported by tau dash, for example.

nchaimov avatar Jan 13 '21 20:01 nchaimov

We may want to also add support for it to some other commands; it is not supported by tau dash, for example.

I like this idea a lot.

eugeneswalker avatar Jan 13 '21 21:01 eugeneswalker

The storage level commands are all effectively broken/useless because there's no way to access measurements, applications and targets in e.g., user or system level storage. Even when tau initialize is run with the --storage-level flag pointing to user storage, nothing happens. The project command and experiment command and dashboard command don't have an option to specify storage level. I have been working on fixing these, but I also think that we should stick to the original model/inspiration which is git. I think there should be a flag to the base tau command that is something like --tau-project-directory that will ensure the proper storage prefix is utilized. I'd rather do this than add something like -@project = ....

zbeekman avatar Jan 19 '21 16:01 zbeekman