pcsx2
pcsx2 copied to clipboard
PCSX2
[BUG]: Persona 3 FES glitchy audio while saving
Describe the Bug
While the game is saving, audio will stutter along for a second or two. Emulation speed does not drop below 100% and none of the audio sync methods have an effect on the issue. The console prints VBLANK OVERLAP while saving.
https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/49990481/199495316-52c1249e-e0f9-475f-a9ad-f5a47d0497d2.mp4
Reproduction Steps
Load the save state/memory card save, go to the notebook at the counter and save the game.
PCSX2 Revision
1.7.3511
Operating System
Windows 10 (64bit)
CPU
i7 4790
GPU
rx 570
Logs & Dumps
P3 audio issue.zip Persona 3 FES NTSC-U savestate/memory card save
I Remember Having a similar issue in the main menu screen of persona 4, But that was in the PS4's ps2 emulator.
Could it be caused by memcardFilters: - "SLES-55354" - "SLES-55018" in the gameindex.yaml ?
Could it be caused by memcardFilters: - "SLES-55354" - "SLES-55018" in the gameindex.yaml ?
The memcard filters are just looking at the current serial + those two others when you use a folder memcard but a file memcard looks at all serials, I doubt that would be the issue.
@Jakey757 you didn't mention Using any patch, so i just wanna clear it up just in case
You aren't using The controllable party patch right ?
Seems like it's been around for some time now, https://forums.pcsx2.net/Thread-Slight-lags-on-Persona-3-FES
i'll try it on my ps2 sometime to see if it can be replicated on real hardware. Edit: it doesn't occur on Real hardware
can this be checked on latest nightly
No change in v1.7.4622. Same padman: *** VBLANK OVERLAP *** message in the console.
Has this been confirmed against real hardware that it doesn't exist there?
Part of a walkthrough from 2011 of the original (not FES) release. Uploader doesn't explicitly state it's real hardware, but it's very likely, given upload date, video quality and the lack of apparent emulation issues. The player starts a save at 8:48 and the music doesn't slow down at all during that time.
I just tried saving with the game itself on one SSD and the emulator installed on another. Even with that setup, and with a Ryzen 7900X and a 6700 XT, I couldn't avoid some kind of audio crackling and/or slowdown. My guess was that emulation actually is dipping below 100% very briefly, and that seems to be the case from my testing (note the brief dip to 28FPS while the audio is affected):
https://github.com/PCSX2/pcsx2/assets/8225831/b6ef46fa-c0f5-464d-adc7-81cadbaed9ab
I just tried saving with the game itself on one SSD and the emulator installed on another. Even with that setup, and with a Ryzen 7900X and a 6700 XT, I couldn't avoid some kind of audio crackling and/or slowdown. My guess was that emulation actually is dipping below 100% very briefly, and that seems to be the case from my testing (note the brief dip to 28FPS while the audio is affected): 2024-06-19.05-01-20.mp4
PLS enable all the options on OSD when that happens, so we can see what exactly is slowing that part on your hardware
PLS enable all the options on OSD when that happens, so we can see what exactly is slowing that part on your hardware
https://github.com/PCSX2/pcsx2/assets/8225831/ff5e0b48-7910-44fd-b887-0e8bd0dd187b
Naturally whatever it is is worse when saving to a new save slot. Here I save a few times to new save slots, and a few times I overwrite existing saves.