Memcard Folder Not Loading for Shadow of the Colossus Japanese Version (SCPS-15097)

[SpiralCut]

PCSX2 version: (For example, stable build v1.6.0 (or) development builds v1.7.0-dev-xxx) Dev Build PCSX2 1.7.0-20200811005056

• Notes: (None

PCSX2 options: (For example, Clamping/Rounding, Speedhacks, GameFixes) Set at Preset Safe (Default)

Plugins used: GSdx32-AVX2.dll [GSdx 20200811005056 (MSVC 19.26 AVX2/AVX2) 1.2.0] LilyPad.dll [LilyPad (20200811005056) 0.12.1] Spu2-X.dll [SPU2-X 20200811005056 2.0.0] cdvdGigaherz.dll [cdvdGigaherz 20200811005056 0.11.0] USBnull.dll [USBnull Driver 20200811005056 0.7.0] FWnull.dll [FWnull Driver 20200811005056 0.7.0] DEV9null.dll [DEV9null Driver 20200811005056 0.5.0]

Description of the issue: Shadow of the Colossus Japanese edition (SCPS-15097) does not load save files when loaded from a memcard folder. I am able to load the save when it is included in an actual .ps2 memcard file, but when I convert that same file to folder the save does not load.

How to reproduce the issue:

1. Insert Shadow of the Colossus.ps2 (included with ticket) into memcard slot 1 and boot SCPS-15097 and the game should show two save files available
2. Convert Shadow of the Colossus.ps2 to a memcard folder through the PCSX2 memcard manager and insert that memcard folder into memcard slot 1 and boot SCPS-15097 and now the game will not show any save files

*Notes: -I thought maybe it was a bad rip due to the filetype of the ISO I used (.cdr) since PCSX2 was not showing a crc but I have the same results (both no save loaded and missing crc) after both ripping my disc to iso and booting directly from the actual disc using the cdvdGigaherz plugin so I don't think it's related. -Save comes from a real PS2 playstation that was converted to PS3 and then migrated to PC.

Last known version to work: Unknown, this is my first time trying memcard folders

PC specifications: (For example: CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo E4600 GPU: Gigabyte GTX 750Ti OS: Windows 10 64 Bit) Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-8700K CPU @ 3.70GHz Windows 10 Pro 64 Bit English (18363) Asus GTX 1070TI

Shadow of the Colossus.zip PCSX2_log_(Folder).txt PCSX2_log_(Memcard).txt

[MrCK1]

@SpiralCut by any chance, is the issue affected by creating a fresh folder memory card and trying to save/load from that in-game?

[SpiralCut]

@MrCK1 No, I tried removing the save itself and trying to create a new save in game using a folder I know works for other ps2 saves. The game will say it saved successfully but the save won’t show up when you try to load.

[refractionpcsx2]

Is this still an issue (if using a new save)?

[SpiralCut]

Yes, I just tried it using SCPS-15097 and this time it crashed when trying to save for the first time. I'm not sure what the files are to upload for the latest versions of PCSX2 but I think I've included the log with this post.

By the way, this is on 1.7.2731 (latest nightly as of 5/10) on the x64 avx2 build emuLog.txt

[Mrlinkwii]

how is this on nightly ?

[SpiralCut]

Issue still occurs on nightly (tested on windows v 1.7.4927) . I tried both copying the save into my normal memory card folder and reconverting the .ps2 file for my original save (taken from a PS3 with the PS2 memory card adapter) to a new save card folder but it's still not reading the files

[refractionpcsx2]

any chance somebody could try this again with #10791 ?

[SpiralCut]

@refractionpcsx2 thanks for checking. Not sure if 10791 is present in the latest nightly (1.7.5560) but I still have the issue with Shadow of the Colossus JP in 1.7.5560

Update: confirmed that starting fresh from a new save I can save a new game and then reload it in Shadow of the Colossus so that does work. Unfortunately, old saves from my old PS2 converted from memcards to folders I still seem to be having issues.