android-messages-desktop icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
android-messages-desktop copied to clipboard

Windows 10+ x64: Native notifications that have been cleared come back when a new notification arrives

Open jdrch opened this issue 2 years ago • 9 comments

Describe the bug On Windows 10+ (read: 10 & 11) x64, native notifications that have been cleared return when a new notification is received in the same session

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Run Android Message for Desktop on Windows 10 x64
  2. Receive a message, which triggers a native Windows notification
  3. Clear the notification
  4. Receive a subsequent message that triggers another native Windows notification

Expected behavior Only the new notification generated in 4) above should whos

Screenshots N/A

Desktop (please complete the following information):

  • OS: Windows
  • Version: 10+ x64

Additional context Add any other context about the problem here.

jdrch avatar Jan 16 '22 19:01 jdrch

UPDATE

Signal Desktop seems to have this issue too, so it may be a problem that lives upstream in Electron(?) Any ideas?

jdrch avatar Jan 17 '22 16:01 jdrch

This is probably related to the other windows notification problems we are having. I honestly have no idea what is wrong and it may very well be electrons fault.

OrangeDrangon avatar Jan 17 '22 18:01 OrangeDrangon

This is probably related to the other windows notification problems we are having. I honestly have no idea what is wrong and it may very well be electrons fault.

I definitely think it's an Electron problem. Does anyone know where the Electron repo/issue reporting forum is?

jdrch avatar Jan 17 '22 18:01 jdrch

Electron has a GitHub page.

OrangeDrangon avatar Jan 17 '22 19:01 OrangeDrangon

Is this resolved with our latest fix for notifications.

OrangeDrangon avatar Apr 24 '22 03:04 OrangeDrangon

It's not completely fixed for me but it's gotten better, with fewer previously dismissed notifications surfacing. I think part of the problem is on the Windows side of things too, but I'm not sure.

jdrch avatar Apr 24 '22 14:04 jdrch

I will try to get back to updating dependencies. Maybe a newer electron version fixes it :shrug:

OrangeDrangon avatar Apr 25 '22 15:04 OrangeDrangon

Has the new update helped at all?

OrangeDrangon avatar Sep 15 '22 13:09 OrangeDrangon

I'll look into it on my Windows 11 laptop. At the last update I was having the same issue with native Windows apps but it seems lately mostly Android Messages and WhatsApp are affected. Thanks for the continued effort on this!

jdrch avatar Sep 15 '22 14:09 jdrch