DVB-receiver icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
DVB-receiver copied to clipboard

Board for Phase 4 Ground

Open ohmoreno opened this issue 5 years ago • 4 comments

Hello @jschiefer ,

Did you get some progress with the design/implementation of the adapter board that would allow us to connect an Analog Devices AD-FMCOMMS2/3/4-EBZ board to an Avnet ultra96 processor board?

Thanks for your time.

ohmoreno avatar Sep 04 '19 22:09 ohmoreno

Sorry, I have not made any progress on this, and have no immediate plans to do so. I don't have an FMCOMMS2/3/4 board myself, so my motivation (and ability to test) is very limited...

jschiefer avatar Sep 13 '19 22:09 jschiefer

I would like to contribute to your project, If I send you one (as donation to the project) can you proceed?

If yes - what's the time frame you are expecting?

I also would like all schematics and technical documentation to be public domain or open source hardware.

Nice to meet you, by the way.

Regards Oscar Moreno

ohmoreno avatar Sep 14 '19 21:09 ohmoreno

@ohmoreno I might have a crack at this, although I would probably be tempted to just stick the AD9361 directly on the board. There's already a project with the schematic and layout I could use here: https://github.com/daveshah1/RFToolSDR

I've also got a design using the Lime LMS7002M I could stick on. That would cover the two main integrated SDR options and could simply be selected by different assembly options. Doesn't really add much PCB area - PCBs are almost free these days anyway.

The advantage of adding the ICs directly is then people don't need to then pay the ~700 currencies to buy the FMC dev board which is a fair bit of cash.

The down side is that it would complicate the assembly and push the board to a 6 layer. But I think this would still give a large improvement on having to buy the Analog Devices board as well. Plus the FMC connector requires reflow soldering anyway so I don't think there's a huge jump in assembly complexity.

yrrapt avatar Sep 18 '19 18:09 yrrapt

@yrrapt Interesting, let me check in detail the information you sent so I can comment on it. The main reason I would like to interface the 2 boards is to take advantage of the power of the Ultra96, and I haven't been able to do that because of its lack of connectivity so I believe that a FMC adapter would be a good idea. Thanks for your time, I hope we can move forward on this matter.

ohmoreno avatar Sep 19 '19 15:09 ohmoreno