lwm2m-registry icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
lwm2m-registry copied to clipboard

URN for `Test` Range

Open sbernard31 opened this issue 1 year ago • 3 comments

Recently, I see that there is a new Test range of ID for object.

Category Label URN Object ID range Description
Test n/a n/a 42769 - 42800 Object IDs for testing purpose. These IDs MUST NOT be used in production as collisions with other object IDs are possible.

There is no URN define, is it expected ?

This documentation say :

The composition of this element is: urn:oma:lwm2m:<oma|ext|x>:<ObjectID>:<version>

For implementation which valid model before to load it, this is unclear what should be done.

Could you clarify that please :pray:

sbernard31 avatar Sep 19 '23 14:09 sbernard31

@sbernard31 the group DMSO agrees this should be in the "x" range. Would you like further clarification in the https://github.com/OpenMobileAlliance/lwm2m-registry/wiki/Guidelines#object-urn documentation ?

mkgillmore avatar Apr 09 '24 16:04 mkgillmore

I think https://github.com/OpenMobileAlliance/lwm2m-registry/wiki/Guidelines#object-urn documentation is clear enough.

But IF x label should be used for Test category THEN I think that Test row of ObjectID Classes table should be updated

image

This table is available here by clicking on Object Classes Tab.

sbernard31 avatar Apr 10 '24 08:04 sbernard31

Probably with something like :

Category Label URN Object ID range Description
Test ~n/a~
x
~n/a~
urn:oma:lwm2m:x:<id>:<version>
42769 - 42800 Object IDs for testing purpose. These IDs MUST NOT be used in production as collisions with other object IDs are possible.

sbernard31 avatar Apr 10 '24 08:04 sbernard31

Group agrees to make the changes. Appendix D needs to change along with the table used in the website

mkgillmore avatar Apr 30 '24 14:04 mkgillmore

Resolved in PR https://github.com/OpenMobileAlliance/technical.openmobilealliance.org/pull/244

jpradocueva avatar May 06 '24 02:05 jpradocueva

@sbernard31 We believe this is resolved and will be made available on OMA's website and will appear in LwM2M 1.2.2 and later revisions

mkgillmore avatar May 07 '24 14:05 mkgillmore