oeplatform icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
oeplatform copied to clipboard

[Scenario Bundle] Allow users to add sectors without choosing predefined sector devision

Open u-mueller opened this issue 2 years ago • 9 comments

Description of the issue

If no predefined sector division (SD) is chosen, no sectors are displayed (this has been different some time ago, and maybe has been changed due to my unclear description in issue OpenEnergyPlatform/oeplatform#1524 ). Since users might be unsure, which from the offered SDs their study deals with, they should be given the oppurtunity to at least annotate with the more general sector definitions from the ontology: agriculture, forestry and land use sector energy demand sector energy transformation sector industry sector waste and wastewater sector (plus maybe even the subsectors of energy deman sector in a subsequent hirarchy). This might be better than losing possible entries at this point.

Factsheet

Study

Field

S7: Sector divisions S8: Sectors

Ideas of solution

  1. Add alternative answer "None of the above"
  2. If answer is chosen, display sector classes from the ontology

agriculture, forestry and land use sector energy demand sector ((plus maybe:))

  • building sector
  • commercial sector
  • heating and cooling sector
  • household sector
  • transport sector

energy transformation sector industry sector waste and wastewater sector

u-mueller avatar May 09 '23 10:05 u-mueller

@u-mueller Thank you for reporting this bug. I will add this to my list of tasks for fixing bugs.

adelmemariani avatar May 12 '23 12:05 adelmemariani

@adelmemariani this seems to be still an open task. Currently, it shows like this when "others" is selected: grafik Instead, sectors from this full hierarchy should be selectable: grafik

stap-m avatar Dec 18 '23 09:12 stap-m

I also transfer this issue to oeplaform repo. I think that is the right place now.

stap-m avatar Dec 18 '23 09:12 stap-m

@l-emele @stap-m Is this topic still relevant? We understand that we should update the sectors that are displayed after selecting "Other" in the sector list.

Do we still have "only" 3 sector divisions? image

jh-RLI avatar Jun 14 '24 13:06 jh-RLI

No, these are our currently implemented sector division classes: grafik

Additionally we have the following sector division individuals:

  • 'BSI-KritisV sector division'
  • 'nace_ sectors'
  • 'CRF sectors (IPCC 1996)'
  • 'CRF sectors (IPCC 2006)'
  • 'KSG sector division'
  • 'Eurostat energy balance sector division'
  • 'German energy balance sector division'
  • 'Renewable Energy Directive sector division'
  • 'GovReg sector division'
  • 'MMR sector division'

l-emele avatar Jun 17 '24 11:06 l-emele

@l-emele @stap-m Is this topic still relevant? We understand that we should update the sectors that are displayed after selecting "Other" in the sector list.

Yes, this is highly relevant. Can you fix this?

stap-m avatar Aug 07 '24 11:08 stap-m

Yes, we also discussed this at one of the OEKG-DEV meetings. As soon as the oeo-ext module is implemented, I will work on the remaining Urgency-l topics.

jh-RLI avatar Aug 07 '24 12:08 jh-RLI

@adelmemariani

jh-RLI avatar Sep 03 '24 16:09 jh-RLI