opendrift icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
opendrift copied to clipboard

Question About "advect_iceberg_no_acc" in openberg.py

Open dayexingyang opened this issue 11 months ago • 3 comments

Hi,

I have a question regarding the function "advect_iceberg_no_acc" in openberg.py at Line 462. Why does the implementation not use the iceberg velocity calculated in the previous time step as the initial velocity for the current time step? Instead, it relies on advect_iceberg_no_acc for computation. Could you please clarify the basis behind the formula used in advect_iceberg_no_acc?

Thanks. Looking forward to your response.

dayexingyang avatar Dec 20 '24 12:12 dayexingyang

Hi, perhaps you can answer this question @AchrefAO ?

knutfrode avatar Dec 20 '24 12:12 knutfrode

The no_acc function assumes that the iceberg has no inertia, so it reacts instantaneously to the forcings, regardless of the velocity in the previous time step. This seems like a very unrealistic assumption but in practise it does not change much the results. Hope that clarifies it.

AchrefAO avatar Jan 09 '25 12:01 AchrefAO

The no_acc function assumes that the iceberg has no inertia, so it reacts instantaneously to the forcings, regardless of the velocity in the previous time step. This seems like a very unrealistic assumption but in practise it does not change much the results. Hope that clarifies it.

Thanks for your reply. It's an interesting setting.

dayexingyang avatar Jan 10 '25 09:01 dayexingyang