ASVS icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
ASVS copied to clipboard

Support "1.2 Customer testing" from MVSP

Open cmlh opened this issue 2 years ago • 1 comments

"1.2 Customer testing" of MVSP is reproduced below:

1.2 Customer testing * On request, enable your customers or their delegates to test the security of your application * Test on a non-production environment if it closely resembles the production environment in functionality * Ensure non-production environments do not contain production data

Should we include this in the next major release of ASVS and/or be governed upstream by CREST OVS instead?

The parent of this issue is #1151.

cmlh avatar Sep 03 '22 05:09 cmlh

I'm not a fan if I'm honest. Firstly, what anyone does with the standard is their choice, we are not governed by anyone let alone CREST. Telling people to allow testing of their product goes over what I feel is useful

danielcuthbert avatar Oct 02 '22 16:10 danielcuthbert

@set-reminder 5 weeks @tghosth to look at this

tghosth avatar Dec 07 '22 17:12 tghosth

Reminder Wednesday, January 11, 2023 12:00 AM (GMT+01:00)

@tghosth to look at this

octo-reminder[bot] avatar Dec 07 '22 17:12 octo-reminder[bot]

As we move with scope more towards "strictly only application", then mentioned customer testing things are out of scope.

Josh can recheck, recommendation to close it.

elarlang avatar Dec 21 '22 13:12 elarlang

Thanks @cmlh but I agree with @danielcuthbert and @elarlang in this instance that this item is out of scope.

tghosth avatar Dec 28 '22 13:12 tghosth

🔔 @tghosth

@tghosth to look at this

octo-reminder[bot] avatar Jan 10 '23 23:01 octo-reminder[bot]

ASVS states "... to a test application with non-production data, is required ..." which integrates with * Ensure non-production environments do not contain production data of MVSP

cmlh avatar Apr 07 '23 12:04 cmlh

ASVS states "Test on a non-production environment if it closely resembles the production environment in functionality ..." which integrates with * Test on a non-production environment if it closely resembles the production environment in functionality of MVSP

cmlh avatar Apr 07 '23 12:04 cmlh