opm-simulators icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
opm-simulators copied to clipboard

Misleading/noisy control mode diagnostics?

Open blattms opened this issue 2 years ago • 2 comments

There seem to be multiple diagnostics now and the resulting diagnostic might be wrong. If I run actionx/ACTIONX_GCONINJE with master, then I see this:

Report step 20/49 at day 578/1461, date = 01-Aug-2019

Starting time step 0, stepsize 16 days, at day 578/609, date = 01-Aug-2019
Switching injection control mode for group FIELD from NONE to RATE
Switching injection control mode for group FIELD from RATE to VREP
    Well WI01 control mode changed from GRUP to RATE
    Injection Group FIELD control mode changed from NONE to RATE

With release 2022.10 this was

Starting time step 0, stepsize 16 days, at day 578/609, date = 01-Aug-2019
    Well WI01 control mode changed from GRUP to RATE
    Injection Group FIELD control mode changed from NONE to VREP
 Newton its= 7, linearizations= 8 (0.0sec), linear its=103 (0.0sec)

The latter seems less noisy. Do we really want the "Switching injection control mode for group FIELD ..." diagnostics?

Is "Injection Group FIELD control mode changed from NONE to RATE" actually correct (then I would have expected a "Switching injection control mode for group FIELD from VREO to RATE" before it)?

blattms avatar Jun 02 '23 10:06 blattms

This is from the standard output of the run

blattms avatar Jun 02 '23 10:06 blattms

This is possibly related to PR #4235. Maybe @totto82 would like to have a say? I seem to recall discussing this matter before.

bska avatar Jun 02 '23 14:06 bska