Viewers
Viewers copied to clipboard
OHIF
Updating SUV parameters (time/injected dose) doesn't change the SUV[Bug]
Describe the Bug
Using the SUV side panel to adjust the SUV calculation does not change the image SUV (except patient weight)
SUV is calculated as shown here:
cimg (t), BW and ID all affect the calculation.
OHIF does it correctly
cimg (t) needs to be decay corrected back to the injection time, so changing the injection time SHOULD change the SUV
changing the injection time from 072100.00 to 012100.00 should change the SUV
Changing the ID SHOULD affect the calculation
changing dose from 588802304 to 10802304 does NOT change SUV
Changing the BW DOES affect the calculation
changing BW from 91 kg to 50 kg changes SUV
Steps to Reproduce
- On OHIF DEMO go to an PET-CT study
- Draw an ellipse and get an SUV value
- change the Injection time
- SUV will not change
- change injected dose
- SUV will not change
- change the body weight
- SUV will change
The current behavior
Changing Injected dose and injected time does not change the SUV
The expected behavior
Changing injected dose and injected time should change the SUV
OS
Windows 10
Node version
OHIF Demo
Browser
Version 119.0.6045.160
what's the manufacturer of your PET images? For instance if its philips, philips give a private tag to get suv values (a conversion factor) and in this case there's no decay correction to apply
The data I've referenced in the reported bug is on OHIF Demo and it appears to be a GE Discovery ST.
We have Siemens and GE scanners at UHN and I haven't dealt with the Phillips private tag myself. SUV should be able to be calculate without that tag if an image is provided in BQML and has the proper injection information included.
I presume the private tag in the siemens images include all the decay correction, patient weight and injected dose into one convenient factor which is great but I'm not sure how OHIF is handling the SUV conversion, I presume its not via the tag since that tag won't exist on GE and SIEMENS Images.
In theory yes we shall be able to calculate SUV without Philips private tag but in practice it's a mess, if you apply the SUV calculation you land on different number than with the private tags. I even seen different SUVs on the same image on different Philips workstations, so i'm not even sure Philips knows how to calculate their own SUVs....
Also you have to which is the decay correction of the image, if the tag says ADMIN it means decay correction are already corrected from the administration time so you don't need to apply decay correction, if it's say START it means correction is aplyed only from acquisition time starting and so decay correction from administration shall be corrected.
In short to investigate the issue could you show which image you are referring to ?
The important part is just that everything is taken from the same reference time. So yes depending on that tag you would need to correct it or not. But I'm referring to not just injection time but also the injected dose. Both numbers can be changed in the PET SUV panel in TMTV mode but when applied don't change the value.
I was looking at https://viewer.ohif.org/tmtv?StudyInstanceUIDs=1.3.6.1.4.1.14519.5.2.1.7009.2403.871108593056125491804754960339
Didn't got the time to explore it but i think is more related to a bug in OHIF as the SUV calculation is properly tested
@sedghi can we switch this bug as confirmed ? There is a problem here and SUV calculation issues are critical as a error here can change the way images are seen and quantified.
Injected dose and injected, acquisition date time doesn't update SUV value while it should have huge impact on it
I tried in the basic viewer and it worked fine check this out
https://github.com/OHIF/Viewers/pull/4147
I also tried in latest tmtv and worked fine
Just to confirm the SUV should change if any of Patient WT, Injection Time, Injection Dose, Half life or Acquisition time change. All of those will affect the calculated SUV.
I can confirm after the PR, the suv change for all except the acquisition time, not sure why
I didn't looked at the code yet, but the injection time has two flavors, originally the tag was injectionTime for old studies and this tag became deprecated in favor of injectionDateTime
So I think we made something to prioritize injectionDateTime and if not available use the deprecated injectionTime assuming the date identical to acquisition date
That special logic could be a bed for a bug
Ok I think i know why the injection time does not really have an effect
it is here https://github.com/cornerstonejs/calculate-suv/blob/main/src/calculateScanTimes.ts#L78-L83
As you see if prefers earliestAcquisitionDateTime
if (
seriesDateTime.getTimeInSec() <= earliestAcquisitionDateTime.getTimeInSec()
) {
return results.fill(seriesDateTime);
} else {
Could you please explain the logic and confirm if it makes sense?
Do you mean injection time has no effect or acquisition time has no effect? I kind of understand the logic of using the series time if acquisition time is missing, but if someone physically types in a new number than shouldn't it use that?
Seems like the logic takes the earliest date and time if there are multiple options. I'm unsure about the rationale behind this approach. Perhaps we should consider removing it? but then what happens if there are multiple from start?
The logic is correct see here : https://qibawiki.rsna.org/images/8/86/SUV_vendorneutral_pseudocode_20180626_DAC.pdf
if Series Date (0x0008,0x0021) and Time (0x0008,0x0031) are not after Acquisition Date (0x0008,0x0022) and Time (0x0008,0x0032) { scan Date and Time = Series Date and Time } else { // else may be Siemens series with altered Series Date and Time // either check earliest of all images in series (for all bed positions) (wrong for case of PETsyngo 3.x multi-injection) scan Date and Time = earliest Acquisition Date (0x0008,0x0022) and Time (0x0008,0x0032) in all images of series
If series time si later than the earliest acquisition time the earliest acquisition time should be used as reference, so the code is correct.
So I guess we need to display SeriesTime in the SUVpanel ? I assume in the PET/CT example we display acquisition time but this one is used only if before the SeriesTime
I'm not sure I understand the logic of "If series time is not after acquisition time then use series time"
Shouldn't acquisition time be the target to decay correct to? On GE systems the series time is when the tech creates the series but the acquisition time is when the image is actually scanned.
Right now if I open a study the patient info panel shows me the series time in the box labelled acquisition time. So might be best to show both.
So playing with this on https://viewer-dev.ohif.org/tmtv?StudyInstanceUIDs=1.2.840.113619.2.290.3.3767434740.226.1600859119.501
This is a phantom scan so it has no sex. If that's left blank reload data won't change. If I enter M or F or O it will change.
Injection time doesn't change SUV. Still not sure I understand why that is based on the conversation above.
Acquisition time can't be changed (looks to be the same as series time for this study so not sure which its showing)
Yes I agree we should display both Series Time and AcquisitionTime (the earliest one)
That's normal Sex doesn't change the SUV as SUV don't take care of Male or Female (Sex is used for SUL calculation)
Outside the phatom study Injection time update changes SUV, i think we are OK for injection time.
Yes also agree series / acquisition time should be editable as well.
Yes the problem I had with the empty sex field is that if you try and reload the SUV on that phantom study (ie change the weight from 6 to 12) it won't recalculate. Agree it is only used for SUL so it shouldn't affect it but it seems to prevent recalculating when blank.
From: Salim Kanoun @.> Sent: May 24, 2024 6:42 PM To: OHIF/Viewers @.> Cc: Driscoll, Brandon @.>; Author @.> Subject: [External] Re: [OHIF/Viewers] Updating SUV parameters (time/injected dose) doesn't change the SUV[Bug] (Issue #3805)
Yes I agree we should display both Series Time and AcquisitionTime (the earliest one)
That's normal Sex doesn't change the SUV as SUV don't take care of Male or Female (Sex is used for SUL calculation)
Outside the phatom study Injection time update changes SUV, i think we are OK for injection time.
Yes also agree series / acquisition time should be editable as well.
— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://urldefense.com/v3/__https://github.com/OHIF/Viewers/issues/3805*issuecomment-2130468111__;Iw!!CjcC7IQ!JvJZ96W0W8TPrvbX20rEY4C_c4nWMG3zMHYKrub6od65y9_BpwNh7HtNrZwZKF7JfhUe-cWeI9NmcqmPDgRvp5x0AFEPLA$, or unsubscribehttps://urldefense.com/v3/__https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A257DJKULPYA2Y5QKTLORNLZD666NAVCNFSM6AAAAAA7YI4MM6VHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43OSLTON2WKQ3PNVWWK3TUHMZDCMZQGQ3DQMJRGE__;!!CjcC7IQ!JvJZ96W0W8TPrvbX20rEY4C_c4nWMG3zMHYKrub6od65y9_BpwNh7HtNrZwZKF7JfhUe-cWeI9NmcqmPDgRvp5yI5vT2zQ$. You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>
This e-mail may contain confidential and/or privileged information for the sole use of the intended recipient. Any review or distribution by anyone other than the person for whom it was originally intended is strictly prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please contact the sender and delete all copies. Opinions, conclusions or other information contained in this e-mail may not be that of the organization.
If you feel you have received an email from UHN of a commercial nature and would like to be removed from the sender's mailing list please do one of the following: (1) Follow any unsubscribe process the sender has included in their email (2) Where no unsubscribe process has been included, reply to the sender and type "unsubscribe" in the subject line. If you require additional information please go to our UHN Newsletters and Mailing Lists page. Please note that we are unable to automatically unsubscribe individuals from all UHN mailing lists.
Patient Consent for Email:
UHN patients may provide their consent to communicate with UHN about their care using email. All electronic communication carries some risk. Please visit the UHN website and search “Using email to Communicate with Your UHN Health Care Team” to learn about the risks of electronic communication and how to protect your privacy. You may withdraw your consent to receive emails from UHN at any time. Please contact your care provider, if you do not wish to receive emails from UHN.