alt-ergo icon indicating copy to clipboard operation
alt-ergo copied to clipboard

Unsoundness bug (cu_735)

Open hra687261 opened this issue 2 years ago • 0 comments

c_735_l_bis.smt2.txt c_735_l_bis.ae.txt

Responses:

  .smt2 .ae
AE(T) Valid Valid
AE(T-C) Valid Valid
AE(C-T) Valid Valid
AE(C) Valid Valid
CVC5 sat  

T: Tableaux C: CDCL AE: Alt-Ergo (used-solver)

Comments:

  • Replacing the line 13 in the ".smt2" file (line 11 in the ".ae" file) with 1 which is equal to ui_3 divided by itself if ui_3 is not zero, makes AE respond with "I don't know" with the four solvers. Removing any or both of the axioms (1st and 2nd assertions) does that too.

hra687261 avatar Aug 17 '21 09:08 hra687261